Diese Frage beantworten

Critical Analysis of Twilight Frage

What do Du like about Twilight?

I know we occasionally get labelled as an anti spot. Even thought we are not. I think its because its far easier to consecrate about the bad points about something, someone etc than about the good point. I think complaining is something we, humans, do very easily and without truely thinking about it.

So, in the true nature of CAT, how about we analyse the positive parts to Twilight.
*
Oh, forgot to say. What I like about Twilight is Jacob. I think he's a very realistic character. Mehr than others I'd say. When he's desperate he stops thinking rationally, he's flawed, he gets angry, he gets upset, he tries to prove himself a man, he's hot headed and defiant. All of these are very human trait, and yes he makes mistakes, but he makes human mistakes. And that's what I Liebe about him, I can relate to him, because he's so human. And I think that why I don't like Edward, not because he's such a horrid character, but because he's not from our era, he's not human, and it reflects in his character, which makes him unappealing to me. Well, that's my little bit of analysing done for the Tag :D
Myf_1992 posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
the volturi are okay but they totally bombed in bd
Frizzhead posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
Totally agree with Du Myf. Edward being so inhumane kind of compliments Jacob (although I suppose Fans could see it the other way round as well). In comparison, Jacob is so human. He makes mistakes, he can't communicate properly with Bella, he let's his feelings run away with him. Edward on the other hand is so not like that. Edward is "perfect", Jacob is "flawed". It's funny that Du can either hate him for it oder Liebe him. I Liebe him.
snoznoodle posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
 Myf_1992 posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
next question »

Critical Analysis of Twilight Antwort

Mrs-Grint said:
Well, even though I consider myself as an "anti" I suppose their are a few things about Twilight that I do like. Like Du said, Myf, Jacob. He's flawed. He makes mistakes. He's HUMAN, Du can actually relate to Jacob, and also why Du can't relate to Edward - because he's SO perfect.

Rosalie. She is my second-favourite character in the whole series (Jacob's first). Usually, Von antis and fans, she's considered as a bitch, because she doesn't want Bella to become a vampire. That kinda makes me wanna scream. She doesn't want Bella to throw her life away, Rosalie didn't have a choice wether she wanted to become a vampire oder not, so can Du actually imagine her position? This human girl is throwing away her life... AND she has a baby. How must that make Rosalie feel? She always wanted a baby, but she couldn't because, obviously, she's a vampire. But Bella gets to have both. How unfair is that? Also, she and Jacob are basically the only characters with ANY depth.

The Volturi. Even though they just sit around and TALK about stuff. They still kick-ass. I have no idea why, must be something crazy about myself. Maybe 'cause Jane ninja-mind-powered tortured Eddie-kins. In fact, yeah it's probably that. The Death Eaters could totally kick their asses though. But they just LOOK so cool.

Sorry for my drawling answer, but I thought I'd better explain fully. :D
- Peace x
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
I get what Du mean yeah LOL though i like twilight I never liked edward oder bella and other main charactersI liked Jacob (who is my fave ch)
nessienjake posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
nice reasoning
Free_Spirit posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
Thank you. Rosalie has alot of depth and she's flawed. That's what makes me like her so much. :)
Mrs-Grint posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
snoznoodle said:
I still think I like Eclipse. This may be because the last time I read it I was still a Fan and I remember enjoying it but I do think it's the most original (in a good way at least... breaking dawn is horribly original. Mainly because no one else could think up something so bad). There was conflict in Eclipse, in Mehr ways than one.

There's the actual fight with the bad guys (10 points for having it physically occur - unlike every other time in the book). There's Bella's inner conflict about trying to keep both Edward and Jacob in her life. There's rivalry going on between Edward and Jacob. And there's conflict about whether to actually marry Edward (at least she doubted being 18 and married for a little bit. Kudos for that).

I also still Liebe Jacob. For pretty much the same reasons as everyone else. He is definitely flawed but he's got completely honorable intentions. But, like a typical 17 year-old boy, he doesn't know how exactly to go about carrying them out and it ends up alienating Bella. He is the most realistic character in the book.

I guess it's pretty hard for me to hate something. I look on the bright side usually. Twilight does have a huge amount of flaws but I still think it's got a few good aspects about it and also it's just a book. I don't think it can really inspire hate. Just a lot of critical analysis :)
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
Poor Jake, Du can only feel sorry for him, he's so desperate to help Bella and he doesn't know how and he just keeps doing the wrong thing. Poor chicken. Good answer.
Myf_1992 posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
i agree to that as well, he obviously thinks bella is cute and he just wishes that edward was not always rigth there like a pit stier, bull ready to tear him apart as soon as he lays eyes on bella. if jake was my age and went to my school i would probably give him reason to forget about bella. he is really cute in my oppinion
valainiea posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
Free_Spirit said:
hmmm probably that last scene where edward finds Bella dying. Lol, its this fascination i have lol. I Liebe seeing people in danger, and watching other people's reactions cause it truly show's hom much someone cares.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
dylin1 said:
dissing it, dissecting the meaning in it, and bugging my team jacob bff Von going all team edward, even though i don't really care who does what.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
MrsEric_M said:
Nothing really, zero zilch, nota thing. Though the part where Bella dies sounds nice. I might like that. Oh and because of all the media overexposure I have Lost my patience with this series and being nice to it.
select as best answer
 Nothing really, zero zilch, nota thing. Though the part where Bella dies sounds nice. I might like that. Oh and because of all the media overexposure I have Lost my patience with this series and being nice to it.
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
Im TEAM DRACULA
MrsEric_M posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
Hey, dude, Du asked and this is a place for anti-twilights.
MrsEric_M posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
We don't mid Du speaking your mind, we mind Du claiming this is an anti-spot when it isn't.
katiecain posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
Nicoleandjames said:
I honestly thought that the only good part of Twilight was Carlisles story. I liked New Moon and Eclipse because I was team jacob. (not taylor laugnter jacob though can't stand him, the true jacob which is Steven Strait) I absolutely hated breaking dawn it was terrible. The only character that I do like from the twilight series (not saga) is Rosealie, Jacob, Jasper, Carlisle, Leah, and Sam. I also liked the volturi i just wished they were executed a lot better in the Bücher to me there was absolutely no point in putting them in there, she did waste paper on them. So insgesamt i did like New Moon and Eclipse, but could not stand Twilight and Breaking dawn. Even if i did like New Moon and Eclipse i still would not give it a ten Mehr like a seven for new moon and a 7.5 for eclipse.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
Twilight_Dream said:
well what i would think thats POSITIVE about twilight, most of Du would think it is not. but i like how its a new twist on vamps and how the cullens are such a strong family. they would do anything for eachother. and i do Liebe romance and Liebe stories so the age old tale of, a human falls in Liebe with a vampire is awesome to me.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
Friendly_Girl said:
Out of the four Twilight books, I really like Eclipse. First of all, there's actually something REALLY going on and not just big words, while I've never read so much dramatic speach in a series with zero action most of the time.

Then, Jacob and Rosalie. Jacob was a huge relief for the series. He's the only one who seems to come from the reality word, he's the only one who seems like a normal 17 Jahr old boy with a great sence of humour. I really loved Lesen him during the whole series. He and Rosalie are the only characters with a real personality. Rosalie may be called a hündin from most of the fans, just because she has flaws, but she's hands down my Favorit Cullen. oder the Volturi. I Liebe the Volturi, even though Stephanie Meyer kinda ruined them in Breaking Down. There definately should be much Mehr of them and not like four pages and that's it.

Also, I think Stephanie is actually a good writer. Du can see it in some strong scenes in the books, and I suppose that that's why her Bücher are so addictive. The problem is all to what she writes ABOUT-wrong messages like sexism and suicide and unrealictic characters. But no one can say that she can't describe a scene oder write a moving, romantic speech oder absorb the reader.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
HyperKnight9X said:
I do consider myself something of an anti, but there are some things of the series that I enjoy. Just not Bella oder Stalkward.

As a guy, I can relate a lot to Jacob, especially from having to Liebe (or close to it) who did not feel the same for you. He has flaws and that's what makes a great character to read about.

Aside from Jacob, Rosalie is my Favorit female character. Other Favoriten are Leah, Emmett, Carilse, Esme, Jane, Seth, Sam, and even Alice. The Filme have gegeben me a better appreciation for the human characters such as Jessica and Eric (I never really got into them with the exception of Jessica in the books).

I don't think SMeyer is a terrible writer, but there are some things that she does not write well. Constantly reminding how beautiful Edward is, oder Schauspielen stalker-like and abusive can be romantic. But I admit her Schreiben can also be surprisingly good and addictive on other parts, especially with how she can describe a scene.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
next question »