Diese Frage beantworten

Critical Analysis of Twilight Frage

Isabella Swan: Loyal and smart?!

Hello Kittehs,

I was watching some WEIRD teenage news programme and the reporters were interviewing some twilight Fans (Really CRAZY fans) and they were asking "Why do Du like Twilight?" Their response was "Because Edward is so romantic and mysterious, he's just perfect! And Bella is a great role model for young girls, she's loyal, intelligent and has a great persona!"

...

WHAT?!

Is THIS what they are telling YOUNG GIRLS THAT WILL, ONE DAY, BE OUR FUTURE?!?!

Seriously, how can they get that idea from Twilight? I wanted to see what the kitteh's think. So, here ya go!
 Mrs-Grint posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
next question »

Critical Analysis of Twilight  Beste Antwort

LadyLilith said:
*Facepalm* I would like to know where the Twihards are pulling this out of their asses. They must be digging deep.

But this is pretty much what I've been mulling over lately. All of Stephenie Meyer's characters have certain titles about them, but that's all it is. Titles. We almost never see examples that have earned them sagte titles. For example...

Isabella Swan:
* "Loyalty." I will admit, for the most part she is 'loyal,' in a way. But she is only loyal in the way that she is completely obsessed with her controlling, emotionally and mentally abusive 'vampire' boyfriend. And she's only obsessed with him because he's supposedly drop dead (excuse the pun =]) gorgeous and 'oh so perfect.' It really is obsession; it could not be called loyalty because it's too shallow. And as another said, she used Jacob as a substitute for Edward and when her Eddiekins returned, dropped him and threw him in the trash like he was nothing. It shows that she's fickle and she just wants a man to make her feel special and way better than everyone else. She doesn't really seem to actually give a damn about them, she seems to have a superiority complex with everyone except Edward and the Cullens, and stays Edward's unthinking, dependent bitch.
* "Intelligent." Um, what? I never seen ANY example of this in the books, none of them. Actually, she seems kind of mentally retarded to me with the choices she makes (that may seem why I have that picture on my answer, but that's actually my depiction of the idiotic Twilight Fans :D Notice I didn't say all). Such as...oh, picking to chase after a bloodthirsty undead being who especially lusted after her blood in particular? A dude who fought himself tooth and nail just to prevent himself from sucking her dry and killing her? Putting herself purposefully in danger when sagte undead guy dumps her arsch just to hear his voice? Just some examples, if Du want Mehr Von all means ask me. But that's the thing, I see no examples of her being intelligent, only stupid. :)
* "Great persona." Again, never seen anything that helped prove this suggestion, only the OPPOSITE of this. Again may I mention Bella's possible superiority complex with everyone other than Edward and the Cullens. She treats the other Cullens with some sort of kissass-y 'respect' (if Du could even call it that), but they matter just as much as her human familiars do to her. The only person that matters (not to her, but just matters) is her Eddiekins. That's it. She sees her human familiars as incredibly petty and not worth her time. Plus she's stupid. Plus she wouldn't know true Liebe if it bit her in the ass. Plus...argh, so many other reasons. But I'll end here. But just saying:
Bella schwan is NOT loyal, NOT intelligent and SURE AS HELL NOT a great persona. Have a good day. :)
select as best answer
 *Facepalm* I would like to know where the Twihards are pulling this out of their asses. They must be digging deep. But this is pretty much what I've been mulling over lately. All of Stephenie Meyer's characters have certain titles about them, but that's all it is. Titles. We almost never see examples that have earned them sagte titles. For example... Isabella Swan: * "Loyalty." I will admit, for the most part she is 'loyal,' in a way. But she is only loyal in the way that she is completely obsessed with her controlling, emotionally and mentally abusive 'vampire' boyfriend. And she's only obsessed with him because he's supposedly drop dead (excuse the pun =]) gorgeous and 'oh so perfect.' It really is obsession; it could not be called loyalty because it's too shallow. And as another said, she used Jacob as a substitute for Edward and when her Eddiekins returned, dropped him and threw him in the trash like he was nothing. It shows that she's fickle and she just wants a man to make her feel special and way better than everyone else. She doesn't really seem to actually give a damn about them, she seems to have a superiority complex with everyone except Edward and the Cullens, and stays Edward's unthinking, dependent bitch. * "Intelligent." Um, what? I never seen ANY example of this in the books, none of them. Actually, she seems kind of mentally retarded to me with the choices she makes (that may seem why I have that picture on my answer, but that's actually my depiction of the idiotic Twilight Fans :D Notice I didn't say all). Such as...oh, picking to chase after a bloodthirsty undead being who especially lusted after her blood in particular? A dude who fought himself tooth and nail just to prevent himself from sucking her dry and killing her? Putting herself purposefully in danger when sagte undead guy dumps her arsch just to hear his voice? Just some examples, if Du want Mehr Von all means ask me. But that's the thing, I see no examples of her being intelligent, only stupid. :) * "Great persona." Again, never seen anything that helped prove this suggestion, only the OPPOSITE of this. Again may I mention Bella's possible superiority complex with everyone other than Edward and the Cullens. She treats the other Cullens with some sort of kissass-y 'respect' (if Du could even call it that), but they matter just as much as her human familiars do to her. The only person that matters (not to her, but just matters) is her Eddiekins. That's it. She sees her human familiars as incredibly petty and not worth her time. Plus she's stupid. Plus she wouldn't know true Liebe if it bit her in the ass. Plus...argh, so many other reasons. But I'll end here. But just saying: Bella schwan is NOT loyal, NOT intelligent and SURE AS HELL NOT a great persona. Have a good day. :)
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
here, here!!! :)
ILuvSweeneyTodd posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
great answer. Du made my Tag
snusnu13 posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
THIS PICTURE IS SO RUDE!!! Du shouldn't make fun of people with down syndrom!
MadamOcta13 posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
next question »

Antwort

LoveDraco123 said:
They sagte WHAT about Bella? =| Obviously, she's not intelligent. Intelligent people don't KISS people who want to eat them. And SURE, Du say she's loyal! I would agree if loyalty meant obsession. -_- Her so called 'loyalty' is just, I'm sorry, CREEPY!
And if people believe that Bella is a great role model, then I'm scared about the future of our generation. =|
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
Indeed, though I don't think she posses much loyalty either, I mean, she toys around with Edward and Jacob, right?
Mrs-Grint posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
Yup, especially Jacob... used him while her boyfriend was away and then chucked him aside like a piece of garbage.
LoveDraco123 posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
Yup, couldn't agree more.
LadyLilith posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
yep, I exactly agree with Du
blaise_jez posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
chagrin91 said:
I think this is utterly wrong to consider balla as a role model i mean whats that good in her personality to be a role model i would say these girls dont even knw the meaning of what a role model is they need to check the dictionary for it and look up what it means the they should answer this Frage i think twilight has alienated the minds of the younger generations i know that i myself at first was really inspired Von it but then i came to my senses and now i know that that was stupid of me.And i dont get the part where they say bella is intelligent i mean she keeps herself in danger of seeing someones face oder voice i mean i would never keep myself in danger i Liebe myself too much to attempt something ridiculouse to ruin my beauty lolzz.Anyway the other thing thses girls need to understand is that twilight is a story book not reality,whatever happens in Bücher doesnt happen in real life Du will never be able to find somebody like edward oder jacob oder your prince charming i think Von twilight people specially girls are going back to that time of thier life when they would read Aschenputtel and hope someday thier prince will come and then they grow up and now there is no such thing as prince charming i say the same rule applies here too there is no edward oder bella in real life theses are all fictional characters made Von an idiot named SM

Hope my answer is satisfactory.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
Wow. I.. wow. You, m'dear, are reformed. :)
renrae posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
lolzz i know what Du guys must be thinking but its just the way i am it is true twilight kind of does suck and am glad Du are kind of back too i missed having an argument with Du and i kinda new your Profil and evrythn got blanked coz Du were moving and everythn lolzz i might sound to Du likea stalker but i was just cheking Clubs and i found thata Forum Du made tats why i know
chagrin91 posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
and please spare me for my bad spelling =(
chagrin91 posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
ILuvSweeneyTodd said:
i don't know WHAT to say!!! :P
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
I was almost speechless with indignation. Almost :)
LadyLilith posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
newmixgirl said:
A good role model for young girls?!
Bella is just a selfish girl, who only demonstrated this: all Du need in life is a gorgeous husband! What do friends, family and being an independent woman with a career matter if Du have this?! I mean please. She is in NO WAY a good role model, even Kristen Stewart has sagte it herself
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
Kristen Stewart can say whatever she wants; she's a freaking pothead! And she's a bitch! She's almost as bad a role model as the character she portrays. Almost. It's really Bella young girls look up to. And that absolutely terrifies me.
LadyLilith posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
Du know who's a good role model? Neytiri, the lead female character of the Na'vi in Avatar. :D If Du haven't seen it I HIGHLY recommend it! Neytiri really impressed me, she was awesome.
LadyLilith posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
I LOVED Avatar. Off subject, yes. But me too! :D
kateliness2 posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
DracoFanGirl said:
*facepalm* And they need to interview us on why he HATE Twilight...
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
=O What could we ever hate about Twilight?! *Attempts to hide snort*
LadyLilith posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
XD Well, it's certainly great... *sarcasm*
DracoFanGirl posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
i-luv-jazz-hale said:
i want to know why they think she is a role model. vamps dont exist so what does she do that would be good for other girls to do??? i am a twilight Fan but this is just .... well.... not normal.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
ilovemichael17 said:
ummm no... Mehr like selfish and dependent
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
cassie-1-2-3 said:
Hey, talking to another boy doesn't Zeigen disloyalty. Especially when the guy you're loyal to appears to be gone forever.
Küssen another boy can sometimes Zeigen disloyalty, but not when that boy threatens to kill himself if Du don't KISS him.


Being erratic and irrational doesn't Zeigen lack of intellect. Emotional responses take place in the limbic system. Knowledge isn't stored in the limbic system. They two are really unrelated.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
next question »