Critical Analysis of Twilight

Diese Frage beantworten

Critical Analysis of Twilight Frage

Do I Make A Point Here?

Renesmee Cullen's existence is illogical. Though Meyer would say "You're Lesen too much into the story," but this error continuously glares at me.

To produce children, three things are essential: blood, a heart, and sperm. Edward Cullen only possesses one of these things. I honestly do not see how he could have gotten Bella pregnant. If he were a real vampire, that would be impossible. HELLO. HE'S SUPPOSED TO BE UNDEAD. The only living thing in his body is the blood, and that's not even his. The rest is dead tissue. Hence the word UNDEAD. Zombies and lichs are undead as well. Can zombies produce children? I hope to god not. Can lichs? I've never heard anything about that, so I'm going to guess no.

Du need a working herz to pumpe blood into the penis, and then Du need sperm to make the damn baby in the first place. Would Edward honestly have any sperm left in his testicles after about 100 years of being an undead creature? I would think not.

I know that was EXTREMELY nerdy, but it bugs me nonstop when Renesmee is mentioned anywhere. It's impossible. Thank you.
*
Du have a point there...
jacobblackfan23 posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
Yes, yes Du do. ;)
Mrs-Grint posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
Hiding 2 comments... click to show.
*
Not really
youknowit010 posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
 LadyLilith posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
next question »

Critical Analysis of Twilight Antwort

1-2vampire said:
no, you're not looking too into this, and you're nnot nerdy.
Du make an excelent point, i also found renesmee's birth impossible, i even looked stuff up and saw waaay too many diagrams for my liking. but it's true, after 100 years of empty veins and silent heart, edwards sperm should have been totally wiped out.

Du dont sound nerdy at all, just extremely clever xD
 select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
LOL thanks! That makes me feel good about myself. XD
LadyLilith posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
Du are totally true! Both of you! I always "looked too into that too"! It's just that it's impossible, Bella says that it's because man don't change that much since puberty until death, but COME ON!!!! They can't just have the sperm in their bodies after 100 oder 200 oder even 300 years! It's impossible!
ashesandwine posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
Cinders said:
You're not wrong, but I'm not one to Kommentar on impossible vampire births, as I'm an Angel – Jäger der Finsternis fan.

Then again, on Angel, they did make a point of stating that it was utterly impossible for two Vampire to have a child, and that Connor's birth was magic.

So at least they had an excuse.

From what I've heard, Meyer makes it sound natural, doesn't she?
 select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
Yup. And I do like the idea of vampire babies. ^^;; I just know that it's impossible. Wishful thinking, eh?
LadyLilith posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
good point =) also that connor's birth was foretold etc etc...but thats going off topic there LOL
Faith-Rulz posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
moo000 said:
Your not wrong, and it bugged me as well a bit. But then I reminded myself that I was Lesen a Fantasy novel and I couldnt really Frage logic that much when the book was about sparkly vampires.
 select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
Myf_1992 said:
I could go on forever on how illogical Bella being prego is, how Renesme is a freak of nature, and how disturbing the Jacob/Renesme this is, but instead I'll give Du a link to one of my Qs about the same topic =D

link

Please read all of the Antwort and Kommentare to get a full picture of just how illogical and wrong it is.
 select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
Night-Sky said:
Yes, that has bugged me too...
Well, its not as if she put THAT much thought into the series as it is...
I think she mus thave failed bioligy and sex ed at school...
 select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
^ agreed =D
Myf_1992 posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
LOL yeah. She fails at LIFE.
LadyLilith posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
this answer made me laugh.
EverybodyLies posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
Thanks :p
Night-Sky posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
Free_Spirit said:
No thankgod someones noticed. This should be impossible and Stephanie Myer sort of contradicted herself Von doing that. But yes i don't like renesmee to much. And no your perfectly right in saying this. Du have an excellent point
and no your not nerdy
 select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
lexie2635 said:
WOW NEVER THOUGHT ABOUT THAT.I AGREE.THX
 select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
OCFan123 said:
I couldnt agree Mehr honestly. It doesnt make any sense at all, and Stephanie Meyer should get her facts straight.
 select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
XChatterbox14x said:
no you're not being nerdy, you're bieng truthful and you're damn right. It is impossible. There is no possible way she could end up bieng pregnant, i think stephanie myer may have a low iq. And i hate how she's 'dumbing' her fans. But I agree with u :)
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
next question »
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!