Both are amazing movies and I've been debating which one I like more but overall this is the better movie. I like Tiana more than Moana (Who is awesome as well), Naveen is FAR better than Maui, the humor is better, the side characters are better, I prefer having an actual antagonist, and 2D animation is SO GORGEOUS!

I've not seen Moana yet, unfortunately

No contest! Perfect movie <3
Moana is such an extremly overrated movie.

Easily. TPATF is my least favorite in both of DP movies and Revival movies

I don't think TPatF is without its flaws, but it's forever going to be a favorite of mine because of my memories of watching it in theaters. I liked Moana okay but was kind of underwhelmed, which I hate to say because two years ago I was super excited for it. I think my excitement died down, so when it came out I didn't really know how to feel about it.