Ok, maybe it was not the best thing... but he did do what he really believe was right

Believed wuz right??? He said he didnt want her... wowza he could have let her down easier!!!!!!!!!

no, he was just doing what was right for bella. it would have worked out fine, but bella freaked out

ADD MORE COMMENTS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

She kind of had to freak out, otherwise we would've only had 2 books. The end.

I agree that he was doing what he thought was right, even if it was a little extreme. But I still wanted to shred him to little bitty pieces and light his tattered remains on fire.

he could have told her the truth instead of lying and it turned out it was worse for her and him both(jake♥ too)

well ...no 1 knos if its the right thing ..but the thought counts.. he wanted to protect her.. & thatz what it cost.. if u really love sum 1.. u would leave if its the best 4 them.. if u thought it was dangerous 4 that person to be around u then no duh u would leave that person.. & wanted that person to be safe..

~andrea isabella~

ohh & i forgot to say.. she would have not let him go if he never said too her "ur not good enough for me.. i don't want u" ..even i would belive that.. soo that was the only way 4 her to let go..still she waz sorta dumb to not keep him around a little longer i would have asked why?

No i did not think that Edward was a 'bitch' when he left Bella, he did what he thought was right.

He wanted her to have a normal life, that's not being a bitch it's being thoughtful.

Bitch, isn't the word I would use. More like naive, actually. He was completely naive to think that Bella could actually live a normal life AFTERA him, adn he was naive to think he cou;d live his life the same way. it was almost, almost unrealistic. Edward COULD have never been that stupid and naive to think that way, but he did. So he wasn't a bitch, just ignorant.

he thought he was doing the right thing but he was only making things worse for both him and Bella

HE is a dumba** and naive... i agree!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

i wasnt really angry, i was more like sad that i cried when he left. But, when he came back that and explained why he left i totally understood why he left.

Edward Loves bella more than life. he would have done anything to keep her safe even if that meant he had to break both of their hearts. He Cant Tell The Future Like Alice! He didn t no it would hurt her that bad (though he should have known better)

I thought some of the things he told her were messed up.

ME 2!!!!

I think he did the right thing (well from his point of view anyway). When I first read it I was really angry at Edward though, and I didn't forgive him until Breaking Dawn.

i love that! 'did you think edward was a bitch?' haha >.<

lol i loved that too
and i was really happy edward left,if he didnt leave jacob wouldnt have appeared and the books would have turned out boring...

He's an absolute abusive asshole, and this just enforces my hatred of his character.