definitely Emmett.

as much as i LOVE jacob... i think emmett would still win

in werewolf form, Jacob, i mean what can Emmet REALLY do to jacob as a dog.?
expecially after he's already shown Jacob all his secret moves
=D

lol.. acctually Jacob has also shown his moves..remember..lol.. but anywayz.. i think BIG BAD & LOVABLE EMMETT would winn...not sure because wolves are thouf meat.. thou i remember Jacob getting hurt in Eclipse.. my a NEW BORN..but he was trying to protect sum 1....lol i don't kno but i do think Emmett would win!

jacob is to overconfiedent...

Emmett is also overconfident. I just think that Jacob would probably think more about what moves to make and such, thus winning.

jacob!

I DONT REALLY KNOW TO TELL YOU THE TRUTH ITS AN EVEN MATCH I THINK!!

it would be close tho!

Emmett would win hands down.

i think emmett i just think more of vampires i guess... jacob seems like a wheenie to me

i love emmett n all but for sum reason jake is so confident in himself and emmett is like a playable bear, emmett doesnt really pay attention and when jake goes at something he doesnt stop till he wins his prize (aka bella).

Jacob Wins

Both hot but in a physical fight Jacob would win. Jasper bet Emmett aswell and Jacob and the rest of the pack killed Laurent and newborns. Emmett doesn't think when he fights aswell.

jake's natural at this... nothing to worry abt.. emmett's more like a newborn.. no offence.. i love emmett.

Mike voted for Jacob, isn't that proof enough?

I think Emmett could eat Jake for dinner, wolf form or not. Emmett is just huge and scary. Besides, if Jake is in wolf form, there's more for Emmett to hit.

I don't care how big you are. A werewolf will end up kicking your ass when in full form. They're more powerful with bigger teeth.

I think emmett would put up a good fight but i think jake would win but i would think that emmett's awsome-ness would make him win instead of jake. That would be a good fight. WEll i think they would fight each other to death.

I'm not sure. I think it would be a relatively even match based on brute strength alone. But Jacob has more technique than Emmett, because Emmett is headstrong, over-confident and straight-forward. Jacob would take his time and be more careful, even though he is relatively over-confident and headstrong himself. I think that based on my assessment right there, I would have to go with Jacob, but that would be betraying my favourite vampire, and well, that's just not nice. haha

Emmett is slower than Jacob, and, again, werewolves are made to kill vampires.

i dont care what werewolves were made for cuz emmett would hands down kick jacobs overconfident butt in about 2 seconds

emmetts got the muscles and Jacobs got the skill. it'll be interesting to see who'd win, but cos i'm a vampire fanatic im confinced emmett will walk away!

Emmett is like my 2nd favourite Vampire, I don't think he would back down untill he wins :]

emmett for sure! he would kill jacob in an instant and then start laughing :[

Emmet but he wont kill him just beat him up...cause emmet not evil he is teddy bear

i love both of them to bits, but emmett would beat the shit out of him.

that's a toughie but i wud hav to pick emmett

EMMETT'S JUST A PRETTY BOY WHILE JAKE'S THE WHOLE PAKAGE!!!!!!!!;)

JACOB!!!