Diese Frage beantworten

Twilight-Serie Frage

What is Twilight's theme?

Can't think of one?
That's cuz there is none.
*
k well my Twilight-bashing mood is pretty much over. I realise now I may have been a bit high on anger with some of my other comments/questions :/ Sorry if I offended anyone
weaslyismyking posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
 weaslyismyking posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
next question »

Twilight-Serie  Beste Antwort

JoseVanders said:
Well I mean if Du look at in terms of how Du would study a text in school I'm sure some of the themes would be love, jealousy and separation. Also Du could consider religion and morality, because of the frequent discussions about an after life, oder the existence of souls. Another thing for the religion theme is the reference to the "apple", and the whole idea of temptation and the forbidden Obst (in this case, it would be Bella). Those are just off the oben, nach oben of my head, im sure if Du were doing an essay Du could look at it in much Mehr depth. So im not too sure how Du can say there are no themes....
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
next question »

Antwort

mandapanda said:
I'm not sure what Du mean Von theme. And are Du a hater? I'm not sure either. But I'll answer your Frage nonetheless. And actually, there is a theme I can think of. Theme in an academic term, they would probably be along the lines of Liebe oder forbidden love. Theme as in, is there a moral? Not necessarily a moral, a life lesson we can learn from the books, but SM incorporates life lessons into her writing. And I think that's pretty refreshing.

select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
Ok I have the perfect response to this but there's not much room here so I'll sum it up: Twilight has no plot. It is pages and pages of whiny rambling and gushing over Edward. Edward and Bella are not in love. They lust over each other. So their "love" is not the theme.
weaslyismyking posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
Has no plot? the definition of a plot is the story. what I got from twilight is Bella moves to a small town. She sees and becomes infactuated with Edward, who happens to be a vampire. His family chooses to live a life without killing people despite what they are. 3 nomadic Vampire are introduced and finds Edward and Bella's relationship a mystery. James is challenged Von that fact and decides to take Bella away from Edward. He starts his killing game. He tricks her. She meets him. Edward saves her. How is that not a plot? I do agree with rambling and gushing. Bella does that alot. But besides that, the story can get deep. It has a lot of layers. Everyone thinks it's a simple story, but under the surface, it can get complex. Take Bella for instance. She's supposed to be this pathetic, weakling. But it takes a strong person to know what she wants in life, and what she'll do for her Friends and her family. Stuff like that. People don't always see it that way. I respect your opinion, and I saw that you're a Fan of the C.A.T spot, as am I. But I think Twilight does have a plot. And in response to what Du sagte about "their 'love' is not the theme", are Du saying they don't Liebe each other? I don't exactly get what Du mean Von that, but i believe they do Liebe each other. Twilight was the first glimpse of love. It was young and new. But throughout the books, their relatinoship grows and becomes Mehr reasonable and real.
mandapanda posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
Wikipedia defines plot as "all the events in a story particularly rendered towards the achievement of some particular artistic oder emotional effect. In other words, it’s what mostly happened in the story oder novel oder what the story’s general theme is based on, such as the mood, characters, setting, and conflicts occurring in a story" Events happen, sure, but as they're not accompanied Von character development oder thematic development, I don't believe there is an actual plot. Maybe Du see some development in the story I don't. And what I meant Von "love" is that Edward and Bella's entire relationship was based on lust. They were drawn to each other because they found each other "interesting"
weaslyismyking posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
there's different kinds of Liebe in the world. And it's not all about physcial appeal. Finding someone interesting isn't always about lust. The first book doesn't have too much besides infactuation with each other. But each book has a climax. But the whole 4 books, there is definitely character development. Bella changes throughoout the series. And sure, they aren't the best written. I know that. But SM is a good story teller nonetheless. Du can either choose to read between the lines oder just read it and you're done. It depends on the reader.
mandapanda posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
Screamer45 said:
Well , i saw a interview of stepanie meyers and she sagte twilight is like Pride And Prejudice adn New Moon is Romeo and Juleit which did'nt make sense 4 new moon becuz in new moon none of the cullens oder bella dies .I'm not sure
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
Hellohoudini said:
I thought Du were asking about if it had a theme song! LOL (Its Decode Von the way) The theme is undying love.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
BetOnAlice said:
The Twilight is about finding true love. New Moon is about losing true love. Eclipse is about choosing true love. And Breaking Dawn is about making true love.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
Awesome answer!
Hellohoudini posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
Jenna4093 said:
Personally, I don't think there is a main theme in the story, but I'm guessing there has to be at least one. I would guess that it would be having the choice of being able to choose what Du want. For example, Bella wants to be a vampire, but Edward doesn't want her to be one. So yeah, if there was a theme in the story, I would say it was choice.

But I think the book series was meant to be Mehr of an entertaining story than a story filled with morals and what-not.

Sorry if this answer seems a bit late, I just wanted to share my opinion.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
next question »