has anybody on this spot seen the C.A.T. (Crittical Analysis of Twilight) spot???

there was a Frage gepostet on the twilight spot pertaining to the CAT spot. And it got kind of ugly. My Guter Rat is, just let them have their spot. I'm a Fan of that spot, but I'm not active on it too much. They created that spot to discuss twilight. The pros and cons. Yeah, they discuss cons alot more, but they want to discuss them without getting crucified. Twilight Fans can be alittle over the top, so they have their spot so they can discuss all the aspects of Twilight. If people disagree on their spot, they settle it reasonably. So, I think it's only fair that they have their spot. If Du don't like, then don't go on it.

But I do agree. They do seem to hate Twilight sometimes. But it's all playful. I even have some problems with the Twilight universe, but it doesn't make me less of a fan. We all have our likes and dislikes in something. Everyone has their opinion. And if they do bash Twilight, aren't Du glad they don't come here and comment? :)

Yeah. I just check it out and it's like all haters on there.They should be ashamed. ;)

Ha. I'm a member of that spot, i don't believe there are 'haters' there and i think it's important to realize the flaws, plot problems, and characters faults of Twilight. And Du can't just say 'it's perfect because.....' because it may not be, it actually does have a few problems and isn't the best written book ever. I don't think it necessarily means they are haters, Mehr that the constant 'so and so is soooo perfect...' needs to be thought about because it's open to question, and if Du disagree it is good to know the other side of the argument. I found Twilight quite an interesting book, but things like that and the fact they are sometimes ignored isn't really right, i think the CAT spot is the perfect place to discuss those things without being shot down here oder classed as a 'hater' because there is no problem with critical analysis. It is merely as mandapanda said, likes and dislikes about the series and any 'hate' there is probably playful. Please try not to be offended Von this oder anything i have said, i am not trying to say Twilight is rubbish oder anything like that, and i don't think they are either :)