if Du HAD to chose that one of the twilight Bücher was NOT in the saga which one would it be and why?

Eclipse, because I didn't like all of that Edward - Bella - Jake dreieck going on...Oh, and that fight was not my thing too...Kinda the lamest book, but it fits well, I guess...I Liebe them all, but New Moon and Breaking Dawn are my fave books, and Twilight is the beginning, so I guess it has to be Eclipse for me...

probably...New Moon, because that way Edward wouldn't had left, Bella and Jacob would't had got so close and many things in Eclipse and Breakin Dawn might not had happened...like all the fights for Bella...jacob imprinting(or however Du wright it) on Renesmee and maybe even the Voulturi would have never caused so much trouble...but still it would be just like an easy fairy-tale...still like it the way it is...by the way I sooo hate jakedog....=P