I don`t want to anwser this :P

i'm sorry... but it is true: at least when you compare her to those other 4 :)

I don't think any of them are bad friends as such, they are/were all teenagers. Compared to most teenagers they were all great friends.

Peyton's been through a lot, so she hasn't always been able to be there for ppl. she's had a lot of drama in her life and thankfully, she's been blessed with great friends to support her through it all. if peyton had an easy life or didn't go through as much as she did i'd be able to assess her differently. she "has" been there for luke, brooke, haley, and nathan on different occasions despite what she's been through. I can't say the same about nathan. He's been there alot for haley, duh. but what's he done for peyton, brooke or luke really? haley's been there for everyone individually too and brooke's been there for haley, luke, and peyton. so tallying up the scores, lol, nathan's the one who comes up short, not peyton. Now granted they've all screwed up with the whole friendship/loyalty thing; but when it comes down to it, nathan's been pretty much the least great when it comes to touching bases in the "good deeds department" with his friends. brooke comes second on my worst category (cause along with the good, she's done incredibly bad things to her friends over the years).

nathan comes 2nd to me, lucas third, then brooke (who really has stepped up more than you'd expect) and then hayley :D

Lol, look at the person who made this pick. Only a fan of Brucas and only answered picks that are pro Brooke. Me thinkeys somebody has more than one account :)

this is getting silly..

hmm i agree with abs07!

I think now - in season five it would be Nathan because Brooke is AMAZING!! But if we're talking about all seasons all the way through then it is definately Brooke - she can be a real bitch when she wants to be.

i think theyre all pretty good friends but peytons been the worst in my opinion

OKAY I SWEAR TO GOD ALL THE PEOPLE WHO PICKED PEYTON DON`T HAVE A LIFE BECAUSE IF YOU REALLY HAD FRIENDS YOU WOULD KNOW THAT PEYTON SHOULDNT HAVE HAD TO GONE OUT OF HER WAY TO GET HER LITTLE BUDS TO BE HAPPY BUT SHE DOES SO HOLY CRAP FRE3AKYGL, STFU & HOW IS IT THAT 2 PEOPLE PICKED HER YET FR34KYFLS CHOICES ARE ALWAYS WINNING

well iactually think despite the whole Brucas mix up that happened with Peyton she is a good friend because she tried really hard to get back in Brooks good books
but i do think throughout that Peyton has been the worst but she isn't really that bad because that whole going behind Brooks back thing is over now and since then Breyton has become my favourite friendship
this was a really hard question!

Lila, calm down!
You don't have to yell like that. People can have different opinions than you without you going completely barking mad.

Anyways, I don't think any of them have been bad friends, they've all had their "reasons".

If neither of you think Peyton was a bad friend why did you pick Peyton?

I think she was the worst out of the five, that does not mean I think she was a bad one.

early seasons she was a bitch

I TOTALLY AGREE WITH s_y_l_a_r but i still think that! Sorry to all the fans of her but i dont like her at all

im not trying to be mean to all the peyton fans but i think shes a bad friend!

Same Question and always the same winner...lol! Ok i'll throw my 2 cents in.

I think when this kind of question comes up it's always gotta be about the Breyton frienship. Im not surprise peyton is winning. Hell when i first saw this question on my update i didn't have to guess who was winning because i already knew. And honestly none of them were worst friends besides B & P. I can't think of one thing nate has done to become a crappy friend, i mean sure he was an ass beginning of S1, but after that. Haley has never done anything to make her a crappy friend (Unless im wrong). Lucas..uhh well maybe he was a crappy friend.....Anyways Brooke & Peyton now they have been the worst friends to eachother! Everyone says peytons the crappy friend, but hello so was brooke. And i agree that peyton was a crappy friend to brooke i mean you don't go behind your BFFs back and hook up with her BF! It doesn't matter weather you two were in-love or wanted to be together...cheating is cheating!! And it's wrong & that hurt brooke! But what i find funny is B fans can say all of peyton wrong doings, yet they can't seem to bring up brooke's own! Which is similar to peytons own. B fans you do remember that brooke slept w/ nate?? i mean yea NP were broken up, but last time i checked they always do that and get back together and brooke knew that, but she did it anyways, oh and not to mention kept that for 2 YEARS!! Atlease when peyton cheated she was actually gonna tell brooke, i give her credit for that! But everyone always say that peyton shouldnt have gotten mad becuz it happen 2 Yrs ago well honestly i don't think she was mad about the ST i think she was mad at brooke for actually keeping it from her & not telling her the truth & for cutting her out of her life for something that brooke did as well, so you see you can't say peyton is the more crappy friend or brooke was the more crappy friend because they both are crappy friends to eachother=]!!

i wouldn't even pick... all of them are good friends in their own little ways... but i guess it just shows who made this poll, right?!

Personally I think it's a pretty crappy thing to make your brother (friend) miss baskets in a basketball game because you made a mess out of things.. also it isn't a nice thing to use your tutorgirl to piss off your enemy brother but well, that was when they all weren't suchm BFFs.. but i'm still going for Nathan

LOL. an essay..?

I actually agree with Leytonfan4ever. Both of them were very bad friends to each other. I still stand by my choice :) I'm not saying I hate her or that she's horrrible or anything.

she is a good friends now but not in season 1 when she went with lucas when she knew brooke were falling for him and at season 3 when she kissed him in the libary but i have to give her the benefit of the doubt with thta one because she did think she was going to die so but i still lke her but she's a good friend now

i'm not going to be mean to you lila, cause i understand the frustration that comes up when someone you like is loosing at something. I guess you'll just have to believe that i do have a life besides fanpop and don't have time to play silly games of voting 57873245 times for the person i want to be on top of the pick...

I agree with tinna. Peyton is not the most horrible friend to have ever existed on tv... she's just the worst of these 5 to me. I can't believe someone actually picked hayley :s

Who are you guys kidding Peyton is the worst friend in the world she cheated with her BEST FRIENDS BOYFRIEND twice. and brooke was such a good friend to ever forgive(which i don't think she should of)

for real -->

but i still love her<33333333333333333333333