I love, in S3, when Nathan pulls the box out of car w/ all the clippings of Haley and they start to blow away and Haley says, " You don't need those you have me" and then they are kissing and he bends her on the car. God it was great! You can just imagine them having sex right there on the hood of that car in the pouring rain, it's such a passionate and great scene!

I agree Lindsey i will go into my reason later when i can think of them.

The 3x13 rain kiss actually remains my fave OTH kiss ever! It was so beautiful and meaningful. I actually remember how I teared up at that scene. lol But I just loved it a lot though.

Edited: Though yeah, the Leyton kiss was pretty awesome too. Heck, all of them were pretty amazing to me!

Peyton died in Lucas's arms, it was beautiful. and at the end when he says your free peyton, omg i was crying, that scene was just so amazing for me.

Im not picking this because I loooove leyton. Im picked Leyton because it was soo meanignfull, sad, emotional and honest. I cried like a baby!! It was great!
Then is naley cuz.. well ElliesOwner already said it
the last would be brucas for me cuz I never liked that scene, Im not going to write about why i didnt like it cuz i dont want to start an argument with anyone...

For me that LP rain scene beats both naley and brucas.

I agree ^^^ with Mary and Ale. but the Naley scene was amazing too.

Deff Brucas! It was very meaningful scene and a turning point of BL's relationship.
Naley scene was amazing but really to me it wasnt as significant.
and LP scene...was just awful. And so was the acting.

it was the speech...nothing can top those words

than naley when he picks her up and puts her on the car AWWW

I fell to pieces at that scene. Gosh it was beautiful...and I had the color off on the TV and that episode was sooo perfect in black and white. Just the rain falling and Don't Say (St. Lola in the Fields) in the background and the I love you and the you're free now. Oh gosh I was mess I'm still a mess it was so gah don't even have the words. Loved it it broke my heart, but it was totally worth the pain it was outstanding.
And yeah after that I'm going to have to go with Brucas. That was great scene for them. His speech was great though it's tainted for me (kind of like how his speech to Peyton in 411 is tainted) because he just has a hard time staying true to anything he says.
And then Naley. It just didn't really seem that special to me. And the I Ain't Missing You At All (I think that's the song that was playing) just didn't really fit well there for me, just the sound of it was odd and it threw the whole thing off.

saBRUCAS how can you say LP's rain scene was awful are you flipin blind!! ok thats all I want to say before I get out of hand here.

ok guys calm down and i have to say their was nothing wrong with the lp scene but i do have to say Chad's acting was not that good in that scene he should have at least cried.

Leyton, it made me all sad and I cried....I do everytime I watch it....(Only like three times :D)I mean she died in his arms...

yeah Terra, i think he should have cried too. it kinda looked like he was trying to but couldn't get there..haha. idk his actin wasn't the best, but i loved the scene, the rain and the color and the music, and just the mood it set was awesome..IMO.

Yep the Brucas rain scene was brilliant i adored the speech and the kiss but The naley one was also amazing

naley's rain scenes were amazing! ALL of them were passionate and heart felt :)

Naley & Brucas!

I actually really did think that it was the most meaningful one... The Brucas one, although really sweet and a really nice scene, was based on Brooke's insecurities. The Naley one was quite sweet, but I just prefered the LP one.

Brucas ftw! The other once wasn't even good.

OMG how can Naley be losing? lol. Heartfelt = check. Significant = check.

Leyton. Heartfelt = ok [I'm giving them that even if I didn't watch the ep]. Significant = not so.

Also Naley but i choose Leyton because i got teary eyes watching this scene!

Leyton's rain scene was absolutely heart breaking & the BEST one. I mean Peyton died in Lucas' arm & told him that she loved him. And down poured the rain..it was heart wrenching & made me want to cry..how can you say it was an "awful" scene?

Naley's rain scenes are cute too but nothing compared to what Leyton had.

heck, peyton DIED. doesn't get anymore heartfelt than that. Naley's was the most significant because Haley found out that Nathan was so proud of her when she was on tour - it was an amazing moment for naley. and WHAT a rain scene! lol. Oh the good old days :P

agreed:)

But, I could be a little bias ;)
But, to me, 611 was just so ridiculously bad that I couldn't take ANY of that episode seriously (and I especially couldn't call something "heartfelt"). And, obviously, it was just an AU. It wasn't really happening... simply a dream/imagine sequence.
But, I think that naley and brucas have been equally significant. Naley are BUILT on rain (that's their little key thing to their relationship) and brucas... well that was a famous moment that will go down in history. Plus, both were insanely heartfelt because the first naley rain scene was the one right before the infamous proposal and the brucas one was the one where he finally told her how he really felt... he loved brooke, not peyton. Beautiful<3

I've made a final decision. I am a Brucas fan. I can feel it! I'm a Brucaser, Jeytoner and Naley fan. But I didn't pick Brucas' rain scene because I'm a brucaser. I love Leytons and Naley's. But Brucas' rain scene is classic! "You're psychotic!" :D

love abs answer as usual hahaha...the leyton rain scene lacks the significance that the naley rain scene has....i think that leyton's scene was the most heartfelt...i will say the brucas was heartfelt on the part of lucas.....but as for brooke she was acting psychotic(he was totally right with this word) not to mention childish and petty....i could go on but i wont, as i believe the regulars all know how much i hate the brucas rain scene :)

i love lucas and peyton together but that scene was reallyyy good