I saw Pearl Harbour, A Walk to Remember, PS: I Love You only once and cried. I cry a little when I see Titanic. But I cry a lot when I watch Atonement every time!!!!!!

The ones I've seen are The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, A Walk To Remember and Marley and Me. The first and the last made me cry, the only reason I didn't cry with A Walk To Remember is because they took out some key elements from the book that would have made it much sadder in my opinion.

Honestly, none of these made me cry. Marley & Me is probably the closest I've come to crying, out of the movies you've listed.

I don't really show emotion when watching movies, but only two have ever made me cry before (neither of which is on this list).

..and the bodyguard and romeo + juliet ♥

none made me cry but i really hate seeing dogs die.

This one and Titanic :/
Haven't finished Dear John yet, just seen half of it but it seems really sad and heartbreaking so maybe I have to add it to the list.

& We Are Marshall

The most I've ever cried over a movie...I'm such a sucker for dogs :(

Marley, Titanic, Marshall, I actually get either sad or nostalgic when watching Revenge of the Sith. I get emotional when I watch The Breakfast Club, but I think thats because it speaks for me.

Lord of the Rings: Return of the King isn't up there? I bawled like a baby during parts of that movie...powerful stuff...

Didn't cry once at Pearl Harbour or Armageddon, famous tearjerks... I tried to cry...

But Titanic, every singel time it gets me. I mean why did Leo have to die... why?

The Notebook & Titanic made me cry, I believe The Walk to Remember made me tear up....I haven't seen Marley & Me but I probably won't because I heard they have to put him down and I HATE when animals die in movies :(

The only movie where the only tragedy that strikes is a dog grows old and I cried like an absolute baby. A couple others on this list got to me but Marley was the only one which was uncontrollable. That says something doesn't it?

So many of these made me cry. PS I Love You probably the most, even though I though the film was crap, the story made me cry anyway.

I'm heartless

And Titanic

Marley and Me,The Guardian, Pearl Harbor, A Walk to Remember, and Armaggedon had some form of tears flowing....but marly and me had me full on streaming with tears

Titanic & AWTR

I was smart enough to miss Marley and Me because I knew the outcome LMAO!

All the scenes with John and his dad were just heartbreaking :'(
I almost cried at Marley and Me but not quite I held myself together :)

Marley and Me, The Notebook, A Walk To Remember, We Are Marshall and The Guardian. I cry alot...

I cried a bit to Titantic the first time I saw it, but after that,never again. I like movies to make me cry that actually take you by surprise that you are crying,not a guarantee,walk into the theater, Good time cry. But the Lion King needs to be thrown in there somewhere. My Girl, A Raisin in the Sun, and Dreamgirls,all have scenes that make you said for REAL situations.

I've never seen the most of it.. But I really find Titanic saddening. What made me cry is Becoming Jane by Anne Hathaway and James McAvoy.. :D

Most films make me cry anyway, some more then others. I cried so badly in Marley And Me, Armageddon. He's some that i've cried badly in but aren't on the list; Gladiator, Green Mile etc.

A good movie, three kleenex's out of five!

*is also heartless*

...or so I'm told. ;)

Me and Marley is really sad. i can cry if i see pearl habour,but not always and Remember me,is this 3 i have cry for the most.

and
marley and me

I cried so hard at the end of the book...haven't seen the movie though. I have seen Titanic, The Notebook, Benjamin Button, Dear John and The Bodyguard (but The Bodyguard was running on a screen in coach in the middle of the night, so I probably slept through a half of it) and I've read P.S.-I love you, but didn't cry during any of them.

Only one on the list that made me shed a tear.