I LOOOOOVE this show and even enjoyed a majority of these story lines, but the older I got the more I realized how ridiculous some of the story lines were lol. But the magic of OTH is they were written so well and portrayed with so much heart that we all bought into them. Anyways, I gotta pick this one because as someone who recently graduated college and went through the struggle....this shit aint real lol. The fact that all of them were successful/famous by the time they were 22/23 etc is so fucking unrealistic!

And I had to add the last two just because it still baffles me that Dan KILLED his own brother and was only in jail for four years??? like no that would never happen in real life no matter how good his behavior was. And I know we all love Naley, but come on the fact that they got married at 16 and everyone (except for Dan and Deb) totally thought it was normal and never really said anything about it is so unrealistic lol (and lets be real, the fact that their marriage actually survived is also very unrealistic)

Agree with all sooooo much!

Damn, One Tree Hill is so unrealistic!

I probably picked the most stupid one, but I remember watching this for the first time, laughing hysterically & thinking: “How ridiculous is this?! You can’t be serious!”

That was the most random haha

+ Clinn being ghosts, Katie as Sarah, Nanny Carrie & Nathan kidnapped the most.
Idk about psycho Derek,unfortunately, I'm sure weirder things have happened bc of the internet
The others could be a bit more realistic but idk, the other five are just wtf :p