I think debating about if the Holocaust happened would be inappropiate.
Also, like Sapherequeen said, things about sex wouldn't be appropiate, in my view. :)
Loopyluna, why is the holocaust out of bounds, exactly?
Ah harold, this question would of been amazing with pictures- for yes it would have a picture of a red and green crayon saying: "Red vs Green? WHICH IS DA BETTA WON!?" This is one of the topics out of bounds for me, random things like crayon colours, etc.
I think this because there are virtually no arguements or evidence to back up either oppinions.
I think anything can be debated. If you wanted to put red against green, you could bring up that red has longer wavelength cones and red takes less brain power to understand.
Just because it's weird, or you don't like it, that doesn't mean it's inappropriate. If you don't know how to debate it, that doesn't mean it's inappropriate. You can debate over trivial things if you want to practice expressing your opinion throughly.
I think maybe it's too soon to discuss it? I personally wouldn't mind, but some people might get really offended by even suggesting that it didn't happen.
I think we have a debate, youknowit101! I'll take green.
To your comment, LoopyLuna96, do you think, then, that offensive material should be considered inappropriate from debates in the debate club? Or is there a certain level of offense that is required to be considered inappropriate?
@pandawinx What LoopyLuna96 meant is that some people claim that the holocaust never occurred. We all know it did, so debating that would be inappropriate.
Of course not, I feel comfortable discussing anything. Sex positions, Muslims, music, shipping... If you don't like the question, you don't have to answer it!
There are a lot of people who don't believe the Holocaust happened. I think saying 'Your opinion is stupid, therefor I will not debate it' is not the right way to interact with these people. I would rather debate with them and see where those thoughts are coming from and why they believe that and to maybe tell them something about the Holocaust.
"I may disagree with what you have to say, but I shall defend to the death your right to say it."
Sure there are a lot of people who don't believe it happened. But those people are ignorant about the facts.
It wouldn't be a debate. It would just be about whether they want to believe the facts or not. It would be about anti-semitism and whether it exists(because they don't think it does while it obviously does).
And there's a difference between freedom of speech and insulting people.
I think that anything should be open for discussion. I feel like much of fanpop is 18+ at this point and for more mature themes, younger users aren't obligated to engage. As for fandom stuff; I think that that's fine too (more often than not, these days politics tend to bleed into fandoms). Plus it's nice to get more chill topics every now and again.
I was literally just thinking about this during a homework attention-lapse :0
The only out-of-bounds topics I can think of would be "Did the Holocaust actually happen?" and "Should we create a white ethnostate?" because we shouldn't be giving a platform to neo-nazis in civil society
Apart from that, go get raunchy with some sex-positive debate questions + ask some chill topics about pizza toppings + swear your little hearts out. The more polls, the merrier.
Okay, yeah I agree did the Holocaust actually happen is a good example of a no go because there are objective facts to say that it did??? Like that's not up for debate. It happened, there are history textbooks, architectural structures, and survivors to prove it.
But if it's not, I'd be happy to post such a question just for the hell of it. :)
Also, like Sapherequeen said, things about sex wouldn't be appropiate, in my view. :)
Ah harold, this question would of been amazing with pictures- for yes it would have a picture of a red and green crayon saying: "Red vs Green? WHICH IS DA BETTA WON!?" This is one of the topics out of bounds for me, random things like crayon colours, etc.
I think this because there are virtually no arguements or evidence to back up either oppinions.
Just because it's weird, or you don't like it, that doesn't mean it's inappropriate. If you don't know how to debate it, that doesn't mean it's inappropriate. You can debate over trivial things if you want to practice expressing your opinion throughly.
To your comment, LoopyLuna96, do you think, then, that offensive material should be considered inappropriate from debates in the debate club? Or is there a certain level of offense that is required to be considered inappropriate?
Except some people don't believe it happened. Why not debate with them?
"I may disagree with what you have to say, but I shall defend to the death your right to say it."
It wouldn't be a debate. It would just be about whether they want to believe the facts or not. It would be about anti-semitism and whether it exists(because they don't think it does while it obviously does).
And there's a difference between freedom of speech and insulting people.
The only out-of-bounds topics I can think of would be "Did the Holocaust actually happen?" and "Should we create a white ethnostate?" because we shouldn't be giving a platform to neo-nazis in civil society
Apart from that, go get raunchy with some sex-positive debate questions + ask some chill topics about pizza toppings + swear your little hearts out. The more polls, the merrier.
"Is the sky blue?"
(except worse coz you're not only lyin' but you're also probably a nazi)
Anmelden oder bei Fanpop registrieren, um Deinen Kommentar hinzuzufügen