Who thinks Tim Urban should have been eliminated?

I voted for him! ...and I will admit that I voted for him cuz he is cute... He seems like a nice guy too. :)

Hell yes. Not trying to offend anyone, but he cannot sing. Like Simon, I think, said: He should go into acting, like something like Glee. He just doesn't have a good voice. And I think he's trying to be like Zac Efron. He looks a bit like him. So, no. I don't like the dude & if he doesn't go Home this week, then it's cause he's "hot". :P

not me he sucks

I really think Tim should have left but Idol is turning into a hottie/cuttie contest. Yes he was definaly voted on for his looks and this, in a way was a very bad move. Sure he might be a nice kid and all but for him to come back is only going to hurt him Mehr as he is standing in the shadows of Mehr professional and stronger competitors....kinda feel sorry for Tim

Yes! He Should Have! Me And My Mom Were Disapointed That He Stayed instead of the other 2! The 2 that were elimanated shouldn't have been!
It should have been Tim and Andrew!

Yes, he should've been eliminated. I think people voted for him and will continue to vote for him for his looks, not his Singen talent.

There is no one this Jahr who can sing really good, so may be it's not that bad to have cute guys around.

Last week i thought he should have went Home but i totally changed my mind this week because he did sooo much better. I really like him now! Hes not my Favorit oder anything but i hope he makes it far! :)

Tim should be elimanated because he does'nt fit in and people do vote for him cause he is cute

I Think he should, but then again i dont. I know he only made it past last week because he is so hot. and he was surprised himself that he made it! DId anyone see his reaction? but i doubt he'll make it this week. (: i didnt getta chance to watch american idol last night but i dont think he'll make it either way. hes not the rockstar type yet. hes got some work to do...

I must say, when he sang "Apologize" I did think should have gone home. However, after hearing him sing "Come On Get Higher", I was happy he got to stick around. He was wayy better. Of course, that's just my opinion. <3 Guess we'll just have to see what Weiter week brings.

I'm not gonna lie the only reason I like him is because he is cute :p there isn't anyone who is a amazing singer this Jahr so him being cutie is a reason to vote for him haha

I like him, but I do agree that the only reason ppl voted for him is cause he's hot. but he isn't as strong as the other singers.

Tim Urban should've been voted off a long time ago!!! like rite after he "tried" to sing "Apologize"...that was HORRIBLE!!! Todrick should be in the oben, nach oben 12 instead of this dude! he's even better looking and has awwwwsome stage presence!
but i know he WILL go eventually..so its all good!!

Tim was ok but i didn't think he was the best one there not surprised he got eliminited