In my opinion Rob has quite a bit Mehr depth to him and so I would choose him. Plus, he has quite a bit Mehr experience in Schauspielen than Taylor does. Though, to be fair, Taylor hasn't really had much of a chance to Zeigen his Schauspielen skills (because no offense to anyone, but Jacob may be a werewolf but he is still an average teenage boy and there isn't much Schauspielen required to play him) and so I look vorwärts-, nach vorn to seeing "Abduction" to see what he can do with a starring role that requires a bit Mehr effort on his part.
Robert. While I like Taylor okay, I feel that Rob does a better job of Schauspielen the vampire than Taylor does of Schauspielen the wolf shape-shifter. Edward puts Mehr care and Liebe toward Bella, whereas Jacob is Mehr passionate (which isn't a quality I necessarily admire). Great. Time for the Jacob Liebhaber to shred me to pieces verbally.
Robert. And I'm not just saying that because I am a Fan of his.
In Twilight, hardly anyone's skills are portrayed correctly. Almost every actor is a decent actor but the Twilight movies, for some odd reason, turn their Schauspielen into mediocre attempts.
Due to that fact, I decided to take a chance with Taylor's Weiter movie Abduction. I saw the trailer because I was kind of interested in the movie's plotline. I was highly disappointed. I gave Taylor the benefit of the doubt, but I just thought his Schauspielen was horrible. I'm not saying I won't watch Abduction, but I probably won't pay for it. His Schauspielen is just really really stiff. It doesn't seem natural and the way he says his lines are just too rehearsed.
I watched Rob's Remember Me, and though it wasn't his best job, I loved that movie. I just thought it was a great concept. Water For Elephants was incredible. I loved his Schauspielen in it. His American accent is spot on in that movie, and I really think that working with A Liste actors like Reese and Christoph helped.
In this business, Du have to be smart and pick the Filme that will mean something. Taylor is Mehr for blockbusters. Not too much depth. Rob is the opposite. He really likes the Filme that mean something and leave an impact on people. Out of the two, I think Rob is the better actor. He's not the best, but he's getting there. Taylor needs Mehr practice. But, he talks the same as he does when he acts like Jacob. So, maybe it's just him. LOL
PS. True actors are the ones who want stories to tell, not just one specific genre. And I think with that mindset, those actors will be taken Mehr seriously.
I think that in Twilight especially Taylor Lautner does an over all better job at staying in character and really making Jacob come to life. I am team Edward but that has nothing to do with the actual acting. I think that Robert Pattinson did much better in his role of Cedric Diggory in Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire. I felt he really got into character and I could feel it even though it wasn't the biggest role. I think Robert Pattinson gave his worst performance in New Moon, something about the way he was portraying a sad depressed Edward didn't quite fit. I thought he did much better in Eclipse and started to bring Edward alive and connect with the audiance. I think Taylor did that all along and thats why Schauspielen wise I think I like Taylor slightly better all though it is quite close.