PPL Fans have been cooking up crazy theories from the moment “A” sent his/her/its first text back in 2010, but some of those crazy theories are starting to look… not so crazy.

Pretty Little Liars finally answered the big “Who is Charles DiLaurentis?” Frage on Tuesday, and it was beyond anything I could have imagined. (See what I did there?)

We learn Mehr about Andrew—and Charles.

Pretty Little Liars has put its core quartet through hell over the past five years, but the ABC Family drama has never been heavier — oder better — than it was Tuesday night.

They're free from the dollhouse, but the Liars' problems are just beginning.

And so we meet again, Sara Harvey.

On Pretty Little Liars, Shay Mitchell’s character, Emily, doesn’t get to leave Rosewood that often. In fact, when we last left the liars, they were trapped in a strange dollhouse.