Same as before. This scene is way too short and don't feel it was sad enough.

Don't know them well enough as characters.

Was the Mulan one fairly eliminated? In your tiebreaker poll people didn't know whether to pick their most or least heartbreaking so I don't think the votes are accurate

i could feel their hopelessness but it didnt break my heart. I did feel quite sad though.

Still the same reason.

As I said before Ariel could have replaced the items easily and hide them in another place. Maybe not Eric´s statue but since she knew where he lived, she could have gone to see him. Besides, for how long she had that statue? Hours? And Eric was still alive. Cinderella´s dress was from her mother and she had died.

The King and Queen... well, they do the lanterns every year waiting for Rapunzel´s return but they didn´t really knew if she was alive, They hoped she was.

@princesslullaby it's always vote for least heartbreaking, in both tiebreaker and in the actual poll. If people didn't know for sure they can ask before voting

^check your previous tiebreaker poll, people left comments saying they voted for the MOST heartbreaking because the title wasn't clear. in fact 2 people commented and said that, and that's 1/3 of the votes because there was only 6 votes. so I don't know if Mulan's scene got voted out fairly

also only 6 people voted and commented on the tiebreaker and it only looked like one person didn't really know what I was going for while everyone else did and Mulan was still the winner last round

Actually as far as it looked only one person voted most heartbreaking and because of that person that's when other people got confused even though it should have been clear that it was always vote least heartbreaking whether it was main countdown or tiebreaker. either way according to voters actual comments mulan still won even if I took out the ones who were confused which was at least one or two not counting you

I don't want to redo the tiebreaker just because one person was confused

I don't think it's always clear because people run countdowns differently. But it's not really a big deal. these scenes are tied anyway.

Same as before. It was very short, and had very little impact for me.

@BB2010: Your tie-breaker poll lasted three hours. I didn't even GET a chance to vote in that poll. I didn't consider that especially fair. And most comments below that poll were all about user confusion.

Yeah... I agree with wavesurf point on that too..

wavesurf it wasn't most comments just some of them and I only had it up for until the deadline was up because I didn't want it to last the whole day. I did it like that before and no one said anything