Dub killed oder improved the humor?

Name animes that Du feel the English version either ruined oder improved the comedy.

Improved:

*Excel Saga: I've seen this in 3 languages; they're all equally amusing. But Excel talks so f**king fast that the subtitles can barely keep up with her & she says so much that Du can only either read oder watch, so it's best to watch it in your own language.

*Photon: The Idiot Adventures: the dub was so bad that it was awesome. Yes, that can happen.

*Special Duty Combat Unit Shinesman: I don't know if the jokes just didn't translate well oder not, but the Japanese language version just wasn't funny.
---------------------------------------------------------------------
Murdered:

*Lost Universe: Watch "Toilet Fears" in both languages & tell me it isn't funnier in Japanese.

*Juubei-Chan: The terrible choice in voice actors contributed to this.

~I'm afraid to even try Gintama oder hase + Guu in English, because the fansubs had me in stitches & the voices were perfect.

*
Yeah I heard Gintoki's English voice actor, his pretty good but since Gintoki's (Japanese version) has just a distinctive voice it's hard to get involved in the anime.
ziva posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
 likalaruku posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
next question »

Anime Antwort

SBTrulz said:
I dont really like subs and all the dubs Ive watched are pretty good. ^_^
Especially FMA ;3
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
DarkJules said:
Hellsing Ultimate
Not only it makes a bit Mehr sense since the Anime is suppose to be taking in England, but it sounds a bit funnier when things happen.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
gkazeuishida said:
improved oder at least stayed about the same:

Fullmetal Alchemist & Brotherhood
Angel – Jäger der Finsternis Beats
Hetalia
Trigun
Baccano!
Durarara!!
One Piece
Hellsing Ultimate Ova's (the ones that have actually been translated are pretty good)
Nabari no Ou (when there was humor)

Ruined oder was just better in Japanese:

Black Butler
Bleach, do like the english version, most of the voice actors were spot on to the japanese talent but in japanese other characters were less annoying Mehr likable oder Mehr menacing same with.....
Naruto

with most Anime its, either or, unless its a long running series. I will usually try the english version 1st just cause i feel like i might miss something either in the translation oder the Anime when watching subs

select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
I agree with the Bleach and Naruto
DarkJules posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
xxtaysuicunexx said:
Improved: Rin: Daughters of Mnemosyne the translation for a lot of the jokes was better and less awkward. It's like the subtitles were too literal in translation so didn't make any sense.

Ga-Rei: Zero (except for episode 12) Hmm, well I wouldn't say they fully improved it because thinking back Funimation did actually screw up some of the translations for that show. They projected the wrong feelings for certain situations. But there are a few parts that did improve/make things funnier.

Murdered: K-ON! like seriously it's pitiful from BOTH Animax AND Bondai

Panty & strumpf with Garterbelt the voices just weren't made for that type of art style. I know they can't have minors doing it but Stocking's voice was too mature for her. Panty's voice was actually good for her but her Japanese voice actress had such a unique voice it's hard to compete with no matter what XD Plus their accents make swearing sound funnier. And because there's so much cussing in the Zeigen listening to the censored version is just "BEEP" the whole time. Though there is an uncensored version but meh....

Just an afterthought but I noticed a lot of people consider the dubs funnier and I think (for those of us that don't really know Japanese anyways) it's the fact that Japan has their own jokes just like any other country has their own so us Westerners might not get a joke that Japanese people would. Du know what I mean? oder sometimes a familiar projection of words in one's own language make things funnier. But of course some shows are just not that great in Japanese even if Du do speak it. Just a thought...
select as best answer
 Improved: Rin: Daughters of Mnemosyne the translation for a lot of the jokes was better and less awkward. It's like the subtitles were too literal in translation so didn't make any sense. Ga-Rei: Zero (except for episode 12) Hmm, well I wouldn't say they fully improved it because thinking back Funimation did actually screw up some of the translations for that show. They projected the wrong feelings for certain situations. But there are a few parts that did improve/make things funnier. Murdered: K-ON! like seriously it's pitiful from BOTH Animax AND Bondai Panty & strumpf with Garterbelt the voices just weren't made for that type of art style. I know they can't have minors doing it but Stocking's voice was too mature for her. Panty's voice was actually good for her but her Japanese voice actress had such a unique voice it's hard to compete with no matter what XD Plus their accents make swearing sound funnier. And because there's so much cussing in the Zeigen listening to the censored version is just "BEEP" the whole time. Though there is an uncensored version but meh.... Just an afterthought but I noticed a lot of people consider the dubs funnier and I think (for those of us that don't really know Japanese anyways) it's the fact that Japan has their own jokes just like any other country has their own so us Westerners might not get a joke that Japanese people would. Du know what I mean? oder sometimes a familiar projection of words in one's own language make things funnier. But of course some shows are just not that great in Japanese even if Du do speak it. Just a thought...
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
I agree with Du on Panty & strumpf ~
lumforever posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
lumforever said:
Better in English dub:

Hetalia ♥ The fact FUNimation used voice actors to act in a countries accent made the Zeigen hilarious! FUNimation's English dub of Hetalia has Mehr humor to it as well.

Examples:

Sub: "I say we hit Italy first cause he's weak!"
Dub: "I say we hit Italy first cause they can't drive and their usually drunk!"

Sub: "I hate winter so much!"
Dub: Winter can suck on my jungle bells!"
__________________________________________

As for an Anime dub that killed the humor,

Panty and strumpf With Garterbelt ♥

In the first 20 Sekunden of the dub I noticed there was already a part that was cut out but kept in the sub. I don't know if that's a FUNimtaion thing oder not but that scene didn't deserve to be cut. Considering the fact that scene wasn't really inappropriate imagine what other scene's would be cut out! (Because Panty & strumpf is extremely inappropriate xD)

As for the voices, I don't think dub worked for this series.

I enjoyed in the sub how both the girls would swear in English even though they're Japanese!

And the voices, just, I'm not sure... I just didn't feel the joy of watching it in dub rather then sub.

The humor? I did find that special "FUNimation touch" to their episodes.
But I still found the sub to be better in other ways.

Also, Hearing a "BEEP" every few Minuten didn't make the Anime better...
__________________________________________

This is only my opinion after all,

Don't like? Don't comment.



~ Lumforever ~
select as best answer
 Better in English dub: Hetalia ♥ The fact FUNimation used voice actors to act in a countries accent made the Zeigen hilarious! FUNimation's English dub of Hetalia has Mehr humor to it as well. Examples: Sub: "I say we hit Italy first cause he's weak!" Dub: "I say we hit Italy first cause they can't drive and their usually drunk!" Sub: "I hate winter so much!" Dub: Winter can suck on my jungle bells!" __________________________________________ As for an Anime dub that killed the humor, Panty and strumpf With Garterbelt ♥ In the first 20 Sekunden of the dub I noticed there was already a part that was cut out but kept in the sub. I don't know if that's a FUNimtaion thing oder not but that scene didn't deserve to be cut. Considering the fact that scene wasn't really inappropriate imagine what other scene's would be cut out! (Because Panty & strumpf is extremely inappropriate xD) As for the voices, I don't think dub worked for this series. I enjoyed in the sub how both the girls would swear in English even though they're Japanese! And the voices, just, I'm not sure... I just didn't feel the joy of watching it in dub rather then sub. The humor? I did find that special "FUNimation touch" to their episodes. But I still found the sub to be better in other ways. Also, Hearing a "BEEP" every few Minuten didn't make the Anime better... __________________________________________ This is only my opinion after all, Don't like? Don't comment. ♥ ~ Lumforever ~
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
I agree, the dub for Panty and strumpf was nowhere near as funny...
Panda-Hero posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
Norge_and_Anko said:
The only Anime that I prefer dub of is Hetalia, which shows their accents Mehr than in sub :) So, I think Hetalia's dub is an improvement.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
Bleached-Whale said:
In dub, I found Hetalia and Black Lagoon to be a hell of a lot Mehr entertaining, but most others just kill it for me, Ouran Highschool Host Club was the only other tolerable one, and even so I preferred the sub.

Amazing shows like Clannad, Angel – Jäger der Finsternis Beats, and Elfen Lied I found to be completely ruined Von the dubs.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
Panda-Hero said:
Improved:
Hetalia~
Black Butler
Angel – Jäger der Finsternis Beats!
FMA

Ruined:
Elfen Lied (although that's not too HUMOROUS is it...)
Ookami-san to Shichinin no Nakama-Tachi
Panty and strumpf with Garterbelt

....I'm not good at thinking of these things
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
Definetly ruined Ookami-San ~
lumforever posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
^Yeah, I can't stand the dub.
Panda-Hero posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
fantasymaster44 said:
i say it depends on which language Du can understand but i can speak so i cant say anything
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
KotokoAihara said:
I generally Liebe dubs and there's only been one Anime where I had to watch in subs and that is Tsubasa Reservoir Chronicles.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
Taiwan01 said:
I don't really watch subs only when I have too because for either they haven't dubbed the rest oder they stopped dubbing them. For me I think the Dubs improve the humor like for Baka and Test and Ouran I thought the comedy was better in the dubs than the subs , to me the dubs make it funnier than it's supposed to be and for a Zeigen like Black Butler I think it's better with the British accents than the Japanese voices. And for a Zeigen like FMA:Brotherhood I would prefer Ed's voice to sound Mehr like a man than a woman
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
next question »