I LOVE IT!!! But my problem is i like both leaders i dont know who i like better!!!

bluestar!!!!!
wooooo
i havent read any of these...i am just clicking on what my brother tells me

NO!! Dont do that!! You pick who YOU think is the best leader here ill help you out a bit!!
Bluestar:Saved clan from dieing and starving,helped brokentail live,brought firepaw to clan.
Firestar:Once kittypet,revealed tigerclaws treachery,saved bluestar from getting killed by tigerclaw
NOW PICK WHO YOU REALLY THINK IS BEST!!

I miss Bluestar D :

bluestar was a good leader and i miss her soooo much, but firestar has just done more for the clan than she did. firestar is more understanding and listens better that she did.

Bluestar was coolio.

Firestar is too soft. Bluestar is the way to go.

Before she went crazy

Fierstar is braver than bluestar though

Firestar is a weak kittypet that will let any cat become a clan cat without even thinking about it.

firestar is the best leader next to tigerstar of course.

Bluestar! She really thinks about the Clan first, and she puts her personal feelings aside for it. Firestar rules the Clan by his own emotions, and he doesn't seem to understand the importance of the warrior code. He takes in kittypets too eaisily. Although not ALL kittypets are weaknesses, the other Clans see them as weakening the warrior code, and hate ThunderClan because of it.

Exactly. Kittypets don't belong in a Clan of Warriors. Daisy is as soft as a cotton ball. She doesn't even deserve the Clan's care. What a wimp!

Bluestar isn't a goody goody softy kittypet! My friend has read the first series and describes Firestar as cute. Yeah that's it, cute little kittypet leader who's forming KittypetClan??

Hey! he saved Windclan, saved Bluestar's live and made Tigerstar (he was known as Tigerclaw then) from taking over Thunderclan, and making Thunderclan slice through the forest and the paths would run red with blood. and Firestar saved ALL the clans in The Darkest Hour and formed all 4 clans to make Lionclan and defeat Bloodclan. But Bluestar has her qualities too.

I have to agree with Squallflower! He has done more for the Clan than any of the others! And I'm all the way reading Sunrise, the newest book!

Who in the right mind would let so many outsiders into the Clan? When Bluestar invited Firestar into the Clan, she thought long and hard about it. When he let Daisy into the Clan, he pretty much said-"Sure, ok." as soon as she asked.

BLUESTAR ROCKS

I know. She made the Clan great.

they were both good leaders, but i think FireStar turned about to be the best

Firestar. He proves that whoever you are, wherever you came from you can still reach your goals.

Firestar is an awesome leader

out of ANY OF THE LEADERS COMBINED

its obvious he's supposed to be ^^

Firestar is too soft, Bluestar ended up going insane... meh, idk.

i liked her up till the point when she lost sight of what was important to her and lost all trust in her clan.

i like both,ALOT!

I mean, Firestar officially saved the Clan, and without Bluestar, he never would have, as she brought him into ThunderClan. And Leafstar is an example of a perfect leader. Kind, but not too kind and isn't afraid to fight for what's rightly her Clan. I just like Tallstar's wisdom. I also really think Sunstar did a great job (he was probably my favorite cat in Bluestar's Prophecy) but not many people have read that book so I decided not to put it in. I added Leafstar only because she's in two books that lots and lots of people have read (SkyClan's Destiny and Firestar's Quest) while I've realized that not too many people have read Bluestar's Prophecy as they have the two books mentioned before.

tigerstar my favorite so i pick him! HOW DARE SCOURGE KILLED HIM

I like them both but Bluestar is my all time favourite.

Yes she did go crazy but Tigerclaw was her deputy she trusted him with her life, I would have trust issues too if someone I trusted that much tried to kill me.
And how can you guys say Firestar did more for the clan, yes he brought back Windclan and got rid of Tigerclaw/Tigerstar he also reformed Skyclan but how did that help his clan?
Now I've left those of you who didn't read Bluestar's Prophecy wondering what did Bluestar did for her clan.

Actully i think i like Bluestar a little better than Firestar.

SUNSTAR!

Yeah, Sunstar!

teehee firefall i love scourge!i wished he killed firestar too.i did not say i liked him, i said he was a good leader.but bluestar was a better leader

FIRESTAR IS A BEAST!

They both had victories and mistakes

DOVEWING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!I hope she becomes leader.

Go Sunstar!

I can't choose >.<

skyclans destiny was AWESOME in every way shape and form!!!

Bluestar anyway!

My top five leaders. Thanks a lot Onestar. You ruined my dream of joining WindClan. Long live ThunderClan!

I LOVE HIM

Bluestar was amazing, I miss her... I actually cried when she died.