For the film "New Moon", do Du think we should see Mehr of Edward? Umfrage Results - Twilight-Serie

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

Twilight-Serie For the film "New Moon", do Du think we should see Mehr of Edward?

66 fans picked:

No!!! it won't be the same as the book

55%

Yes!!! we need our dose of Edward!

29%

Don't mind as long as it keeps other parts of the book the same

17%

beccahalocullen posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr

Make your pick! | next poll >>

23 comments

	mandapanda said: More Edward as in adding scenes? like from his POV? I just want them to sort of ellaborate on the b-day party and the forest talk, then go to Jacob and Bella, and finish off with the Italy part, which I would like to be really long! as long as they keep to the book I'm fine... posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr. last edited Vor mehr als einem Jahr

	Kaidi picked No!!! it won't be the same as the book: It would be sad , but it's the best if they stick to the book ;) posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.

	katlynncore picked No!!! it won't be the same as the book: ^^yes i agree, we need to miss him the same way bella does, so his re-entrance is that much greater posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.

	beccahalocullen said: lol what if they moved back and forth from edward to bella and jacob? like show where he is and like show his pain he mentions in the book when he was apart from her. posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.

	s3ptamber picked No!!! it won't be the same as the book: I really want him to be more in the movie.. but according to the book, i don't think he'll be there as we want :( but i like jake too so i'm happy that we'll see him! posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.

	bluefeet picked No!!! it won't be the same as the book: i hate when movies aren't at all like the book. We still get a heck of a lot of edward near the end. Jacob is the main part of New Moon. That's what the movie should be, too posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.

	beccahalocullen said: yeh but its at the end lol. if the film has like a quater of jacob then thats ok by me lol posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.

	nataliejade picked No!!! it won't be the same as the book: As much as i am Team Edward! I really really loved New Moon, so i would prefer them to stick to the book. posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.

	GilraenElendil picked No!!! it won't be the same as the book: A glimpse at the end and his voice througout the movie would be enough... at least he wont be MIA from the movie. posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.

	beccahalocullen said: lol ok. posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.

	CullenCult picked Yes!!! we need our dose of Edward!: I would like to see it when Rosalie calls him. And maybe just a little of him off on his own. posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.

	beccahalocullen said: lol that would be good posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.

	teNaxx picked Yes!!! we need our dose of Edward!: Yes, I'm very interested in what he was doing and how he was feeling while away. posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.

	mayra7632000 picked Don't mind as long as it keeps other parts of the book the same: it would be cool if they showed more of him in New Moon...but i think they should make him do scenes for eclipse since he can never age...if they can do it. i also like CullenCult's idea =D posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.

	sweet_twilight picked Yes!!! we need our dose of Edward!: I agree with most of you. I want them to add the outtakes. The part where Edward is depressed and he gets Rosalie's call about Bella and Alice talking to Rosalie about what really happened. They should have that. I think that will add a bit more to the Edward fix. I really do want thme to stick to the book. I think the book is the perfect size for a movie. They should extend the Birthday Scene and the Forest Scene. They should probably show the main points between Jacob and Bella. Like the motorbikes, cliff diving and the date. Because there are heaps of scenes between Bella and Jacob and that wont be able to fit all in the book. The ending has to be there too. The journey with Alice and Italy! Espeically the Volutri because they set the story out. posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.

	xxxmermaidsxxx picked No!!! it won't be the same as the book: we need lots of Jacob!! =P posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.

	vianessvondrak picked Yes!!! we need our dose of Edward!: yes!!! it would be incredible.. just imagine edward at brasil!!!! yes to add he outakes!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.

	Lau-rawr picked Don't mind as long as it keeps other parts of the book the same: I think they should keep mainly to the book but i would like to see some scenes to show how Edward (and the rest of the cullens) are dealing with life without Bella. And i definatley want to see his pov when Rosalie rings him to tell him Bella's dead that would be soo cool, and mayb some Alice pov where we can see her visions!! posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.

	doyouknow picked Don't mind as long as it keeps other parts of the book the same: I'd like to see what Edward was going through posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.

	spikes_girl picked No!!! it won't be the same as the book: although i'll still miss him posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.

	xoxinkheartxox picked No!!! it won't be the same as the book: no i dont think that they should add more edward because it wouldnt be the same as the book (not that i wouldnt mind seeing more of him i mean his HOT!!) posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.

	beccahalocullen said: lol. good points. well its not the film their making of the book and well u saw in twilight film that they added the build up to james, laurent and victoria coming. posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.

	yllom picked No!!! it won't be the same as the book: i love edward....but this is about the jacob-bella relationship......stick to the book.....we need to feel the seperation anxiety bella feels...the pain in her chest.....myers aint no fool!!!!!! posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.