Bella: Did she ever Liebe Jacob? Was she in Liebe with Jacob? They're different things. I'm just interested in seeing the different answers.

I agree with you, mandapanda. But the thing is, Bella love(d) Jacob, just never in that way. She loved him Mehr as a brother, not as a lover. (Tee hee...that rhymes.)

Bella sagte that she loved jacob but she wasnt really in Liebe with him.She sagte that he felt like a important part of her family, so it was like family Liebe but probaly a little stronger oder something like that.thats what I think!

yes she did Liebe him but she was never in Liebe with him

I believe so yes. 'Jacob was right. He’d been right all along. He was Mehr than just my friend. That’s why it was so impossible to tell him goodbye — because I was in Liebe with him. Too. I loved him, much Mehr than I should, and yet, still nowhere near enough. I was in Liebe with him, but it was not enough to change anything; it was only enough to hurt us both more.' Eclipse page 528. and I think says 'I was in Liebe with him' twice to emphasize that. The Zitate Du gave, I believe, are before she realizes she is in Liebe with him, which happens when she kisses him (where my quote is from). But I think it's just up to everyone to make their opinion on it.

no i dont think so....... i think she loved Edward collan not jacob but i think jacob loves bella LOL ...... so thats it really thats what i think
from

twilightxoxox :)