Diese Frage beantworten

Das Phantom der Oper Frage

Why do some E/C shippers Liebe LND for its E/C shipping efforts?

I just personally think Erik and Christine don't deserve a Liebe story of nonsense and offense. Let me explain my point of view;

1.) Their moonless night shag just couldn't happen (like that if at all), not even with the film relationship. I'd appreciate their E/C shipping intent Mehr if they at least cared about it enough to make its storyline logic. Not only is it nonsense, but...

2.) It makes me go "IAAAAAHHH O____O !!!!" any time I think of how "Benath the Moonless Sky" literally has them not deal with any emotions but just get it on without any emotion behind the actual sex either. Not to mention that it makes it sound like she'd have never done it if she'd actually had to look at him - so, like, thank God it was pitch black moonless night and we were too horny to find a spot with any light!!11 And then he just runs the hell away while she sleeps instead of embracing the fact that she came back?

The whole concept of their night is about as far from Liebe as it can get. It's compareable to a drunken one-night stand between two ex-lovers because they are just so horny. Add to that how it made her utterly immoral; to cheat on Raoul like that and still go on and marry the man. It makes me sick.

3.) He lets people talk about and do to Christine whatever the hell they want and doesn't do much about it. (Madam Giry bashing her, Meg shooting her, Raoul being a drunken asshole.) WHAT THE HELL!!?

4.) Christine dies because he's stupid enough to worship her to a lunatic who is knowingly trying to murder her (Christine's) child.

In short; I personally see that storyline as shipping E/C but screaming hatred for the ship. Starting from a nonsense, emotionless sexing, seperating them AGAIN because of the man's stupidity, all the way to killing off the woman because of the man's stupidity.

There. Any LND Liebhaber care to give me another point of view for the E/C shipment of LND?
*
Oh and the farewell KISS with his dying Liebe in his arms might be emotional and touching even to me if everything else about the storyline was, like, completely the opposite and especially the scene that lead to her dying. But its all utter nonsense and ridiculous drama. Makes me unable to take the death scene seriously oder care about the characters, who apparently aren't even the Erik and Christine I fell in Liebe with.
bendaimmortal posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
LOL. And now the "fixed" Australian production went on making Erik blackmail Christine with her own child's life just so he could hear her sing once more. The least romantic thing ever, in fact it's not at all but totally SICK, Not to mention totally unforgivable, and still Christine remains madly in Liebe with him - (ohmygod, poor Gustave!) - and seeing to that Erik never even apologizes for that blackmail oder realize it was wrong...ALW really doesn't give a shit about respect and logic for this E/C shipment of his. I'm seriously starting to Mitmachen the "conspiracy theory" group believing LND is nothing Mehr but ALW's fantasy-revenge to his ex-wife, on the expense of our beloved Erik, Christine and Raoul.
bendaimmortal posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
 bendaimmortal posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
next question »

Das Phantom der Oper Antwort

Phantomess said:
Personally, I'm in the camp that subscribes to the 'conspiracy theory' that LND is--at least in part--an elaborate revenge Fantasy of ALW towards Sarah Brightman.
Du will note that although she's supposedly now randomly madly in Liebe with the Phantom, HE leaves HER. And she's miserable. And her new man sucks. And the Phantom now has all teh wimmenz! And he's reverse aging too, so there!
Then Christine comes toddling back, is obviously still into him, but torn up about getting back with him. And then she dies.
Du cannot tell me that ALW didn't have any idea how people would react to that kind of nonsense. Especially since in the past he has compared himself to the Phantom. Hell, in one of the Behind the Mask documentaries a couple other people did as well. Noting that he's not exactly a looker, but he wrote this beautiful beautiful thing for his gorgeous paramour.
I don't think that this was ever intended to be E/C. If it was, we'd get a happily ever after that would make Du diabetic just from watching it.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
LOL. Well, you're probably right. But whatever ALW's meaning, nonetheless LND DOES have obvious E/C shipping aspects and which some E/C shippers squee over and I really would like to know why the hell? Hence, the way I see those aspects as I reasoned in the Frage details.
bendaimmortal posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
greendayjenny said:
ALW messed up BIG when he created LND i'll NEVER watch it EVER. becuz Erik doesn't need a twit like Christine and a son 2 hold him back in his life, his 1st and only real Liebe is in his music, that's the only place where he can be himself. i Liebe u Erik, u don't need Christine!!!!
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
the last two sentences were like if Du were talking from my heart! beautyful comment!
wanderingchild7 posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
next question »