Could this be it?

avatarluver990 No, Persephone is not Piper's mom....it's someone you'd LEAST suspect...at least it was to me. But no, Piper isn't the daughter of Persephone, they kinda do look alike, but Persephone isn't the one. Besides, she's loyal to Hades, even though Hades had demigod kids, she's still loyal to him.

melliandra um ive read the book now and i don't care if i spoil it for everyone else but Aphrodite is pipers mom not persephone

HecateA The book has been out since last October, the spoiler-alerts have pretty much died out. And I know, but onw of the leading theories BEFORE the book came out was Persephone.

girlybella I kinda guessed her mom would be Aphrodite even BEFORE the book came out. I mean it was high time an Aphrodite kid got some of the spotlight, and she could convince people and stuff. That seemed like an Aphrodite thing.

rapunzeleah123 @Hecate and girlybella - I agree.

athena305 May I just say something about the trio(s). In the Heroes of olympus, the trio is Jupiter, Hephaestus, and Aphrodite. In Percy Jackson, it's Poseidon, satyr, and Athena. Another way to think of it is the sky, the mechanic, and the beauty. The sea, nature, and the brain. Opposites attract, huh? Something to think about...

seaweedbrain22 athena305 is right. i noticed that too.

HecateA I think it spices things up. It would be boring if it was just 3 nature-lovers. It also makes it saffer. Like, if the trio's only weapon would have been fire, they'd be dead at Midas' mansion. If Percy and Grover wouldn't have had Annabeth, they would have done so many stupid things...

irinaspasky um I know she looks like persaphone but still no her mom is apradite like it or not

puggyluv17 wish they had a better pic of piper on the internet

puggyluv17 piper is pretty so she has to be aphrodites daughter and her dad is supposedly a hunky guy in his like40s phhh? i pictured persephone more like the movie showed it. one of the small list of things i agree with the movie.

HecateA irinaspasky- This was posted BEFORE the book was out- like I said before. puggyluv17- Check Burdge-Bug's gallery- Piper looks gooood...

eggylove58 i cant wait till the next book comes out. IM RUNNING OUT OF BOOKS/HOBBIES!im 14 and ive allready done everything

Blaze_of_Ares athena305 would it not be Poseidon, Pan, and Athena not Poseidon, satyr, and Athena

icuSTALKER I see the resemblance Hecate is talking about now........ :D

demigodgirl11 Blaze_of_Ares well pan is not grovers dad so it would be posideon, ?, and athena... and dont forget the son of neptunes main characters are hazel frank and percy, hades, ares, and again posideon.

HecateA Pan and Dionysus are the patrons of satyrs though, right?

goddessgirl yeah, they are i guess

Bookruler133 Piper doesn't give that beauty the book gives us, I feel this would be a different person, no offense to the illastrator of the picture.

meredog What do u mean "could this be it?" ?

extremeriordan I don't get it. And I am a huge fan

puggyluv17 ^^ it's an old pic trying to decide who pipers mom is :)