It's in my top 5 shows. <3 Though when I go back now to rewatch, the first season is kinda eh IMO and just certain things/characters bother the hell out of me throughout the seasons, but overall.. love it.

I'm a fan but I'm not a blind one. 3A and 4 sucked.

^ Loving season 3A and 4 is not being blind. It's all about how we look at it! Why did you hate them?

They were just as good as the others for me and for many reasons: Season 4 had one of the most intense storylines (The deadpool) it was also the most adult drama storyline... There were a lot of funny moments, we were introduced to some amazing new characters! I still loved all the old main characters... The only things I was a little critic about was; I was not convinced that the Bezerkers were supposed to be stronger and tougher than demons (The Oni). Also some of the things with Peter and Kate didn't really make sense. But other than that it was a very stable and intense, funny and dramatic season... I really will never understand why so many hate it! And they often don't explain... It just sucks... I'm guessing that for many people it's because we lost someone like Allison and Isaac so now people are not okay with new faces

^^ For me, 3a sucked because I hated the villains. Jennifer was alright, but the Alpha pack was atrocious and so pointless and not even scary and all the slow-mo fighting done that season was embarrassingly bad. Plus it's the season where the show started taking itself way too seriously, stopped proper character development, focused way too much on the (nonsensical) fast-paced plotlines, added so many new characters that I felt I hardly knew the old ones, and lost ALL sort of continuity. It went from a campy, lighthearted show to a wannabe-AHS mess that season.

The only reason 3B was even good was because they gave the spotlight to the one actually decent actor on the show. Plus I have a soft spot for slow-descent-into-madness psychological plotlines.

As for season 4, I will once again bring up lack of character development and continuity. Charcters were constantly pushed aside in favor of shitty plotlines with plotholes larger than the Grand Canyon, and all possible emotional development was supposedly done off-screen because ~no one wants to see people mourning their dead friends for more than one episode~ or some bullshit like that. Not like mourning adds a lot to a character's development or anything (/sarcasm). Everything started becoming predictable, the dialogue was laughably bad, the fighting was even worse, the young actors were AWFUL and were all character tropes Jeff had done before, questions were opened and never explained, and once again the villains sucked. Aside from the ridiculous fact that we were supposed to believe TEENAGE ASSASSINS could happen, the Mute served absolutely no purpose, Kate was just annoying, and the berserkers weren't even scary because there was never any real danger that they would hurt the main characters. Oh, and this is also the season Kira became Allison 2.0. Why even make her a fucking kitsune if she's not going to use her powers and instead just be ~naturally perfect~ with a katana?

For the record, I was HAPPY to see Allison go because I always hated her, and I gave zero fucks about Isaac leaving. I don't mind new characters, I just mind new characters who Jeff puts zero effort into developing...Which is all of his new characters since season 2.

All of this shit is on top of the fact that Jeff only seems to ever add basic white boys to the show, which is getting really boring at this point. It's getting hard for me to tell all these bland ass wonder bread twinks apart.

Once again, this is all in my opinion :) Not trying to start a fight or anything haha. Also I watched 3A and 4 agesss ago so it's not that fresh in my mind (if it was, I definitely would've given more examples).

^ Well everyone has their opinions! And you actually kinda remind me of my brother... He is barely ever satisfied with anything it's always either terrible or OKAY!. But I'm actually really happy that I have such an easy time loving stuff! Because I really do and that's only a good thing because that way I enjoy things a lot more than someone like my brother.

For me though Jennifer wasn't just okay... She is my second favorite villain ever of TW: Because she is very well done, she's complex, it's easy for me to sympathize for her, she's really sweet before she reveal herself as a villain... Her villain side is also really cool and awesome xD.

I can actually understand some of the things you mention about season 4, like teenage assassins being ridiculous but I personally think all the great things tops the bad by far!