icons from link

i'll be back in an hour and ten minutes to make my pick. :)

Oh Dean :( You poor baby .. *cries*

Sam totally deserved that beatdown. He made Dean lose EVERYTHING. Lisa and Ben. His normal life. *sigh* He made Dean doubt himself. Sam = Stupid Fucking LIAR. I am not impressed. I'm kind of excited to see what Dean does with him. Another lock down session? Maybe Cas will have the answers. (I haven't seen next weeks promo yet ;))

Oh. My. Gosh. this episode was So freaking EPIC/INTENSE. I loved it. it was just like... wow. We finally got some answers about Sammy. I can't wait for the next episode!

BBBBBOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOO­OOM­MMM­MMM­MMM­MMM­MMM­MMM­MMM­MMM­MMM­MMM­MMM­MMM­MMM­MM
^my mind right now.......Wow that was freaking intense.....can't say anything else....still trying to process.......

WOOOOAH CRAZY EPISODE.

I'm like wow. Like last week I'm still standing by Sammy. I knew it wasn't REALLY him and it's true, it's not his fault he came back from hell without a soul!! How can that be his fault? He lied, that was wrong, and he watched Dean get bitten, also wrong, but he's scared. He was in worse parts of hell then Dean was, and he dosen't even have his soul. Poor Sam. I feel for Dean though too, obviously, IDK if the beating was so necessary though..

Dude. You can't say that. You can't call one level of Hell worse then another. Nope. Nope. Nope. I don't buy it - I don't care what the writers/(anyone else) say(s). Hell is hell.

wow deans anger,would scare john if he was alive,feel sorry for sam,but lying to dean is big for him.but poor sam didn,t need to get really hit that much,il love them both either way can,t wait for more episodes.one question how was dean at last season able to kill the whore when you have to beleive.thksx love dean and sam

Dean was able to kill the whore because he was the chosen vessal for heaven. [he was supposed to say yes to Michael]

GREAT episode !

Holy shit pretty AMAZING season so far! And one hell of an awesome episode!
Bye Lisa and Ben anyone who wanted Lisa out surely can't be happy now after watching Dean's hurt face!
"My skin crawls when I'm in the same room as him." tried hard not to cry there! My heart once again broke into million pieces after Dean's confession and I wanted to shout him, you are not a killer but a HERO!!
Poor Sammy..where’s your soul dude?? Did you sold it or was it taken away?? What the hell is going on?! But at least the search for his soul will start and they will help him! Can't wait to see actually Sammy back!
And watching Dean beating up Sam my mind went to Cas beating up Dean the previous season and I thought: Could it be, Dean's beating up Sam so hard to see if he can actually feel something?

And btw BOBBY GETS PEDICURES :O

I agree with @Dean-girlx, there isn't a worse level of Hell that Sammy was in, and if you were going to argue about who had a worse time in Hell then I'm pretty sure Dean would win anyway, since (from everything I've heard) it seems like Sammy was in Hell for a MUCH shorter period of time than Dean was.

Anyway this episode freaking broke my heart. Just watching Dean so completely broken. He did want a normal life, he did want Lisa/Ben, but he doesn't feel like he deserves it. I know Dean is meant to be a hunter, but I just wish he wouldn't hate on himself so much. Ahhh broke my heart, couldn't believe what Lisa said to Dean. I wanted to burst through the TV and hug him!

And yes, poor Sammy. I miss old Sammy...you know the one WITH a soul and whatnot...I hope Cas can help Dean get him back. Sammy needs his soul, or else he is just Sam. :(

LOL i LOVED the bobby truth part XD XD

Dude. You can't say that. You can't call one level of Hell worse then another. Nope. Nope. Nope. I don't buy it - I don't care what the writers/(anyone else) say(s). Hell is hell.

Alright, I'll give you that. I really do. But I mean it's not Sam's fault he has no soul, he DID lie to Dean, I DNW that either, it's shit, but he dosen't have his soul. THAT'S why I feel for him.

@Tazoulini I thought the same about Dean beating up Sam....

This show is going to be the death of me, and we still have more to watch!!! Damn Kripke and Sera..

(we aren't called psychic buddies by chance sweet Ambrs! :)
@Pi Agree, Bobby's part was highlarious!)

This show is going to be the death of me, and we still have more to watch!!! Damn Kripke and Sera..

^truefacts

‘You can’t Handle the truth’
So much better than last weeks episode (in my opinion).

First and foremost, hearing the truth from Bobby, hilarious. And second, when Sam said he couldn’t feel anything, I knew right away his soul was gone or broken. I’ve been thinking that since the season premiere.

Seeing Castiel every once and a while isn’t working for me, and I’m so happy he’ll be in next week’s episode. Love him.

All in all, terrific episode!

Holy crap, I never thought I'd see the day when Dean actually took his frustrations/fears out on Sam like that.

I feel bad for Sam but not too bad. He tried until the last second to keep the truth from Dean. The only reason he admitted anything was because Dean was about to kill him. I'm not sure he even really wants help. I think he just said that because he knew it would stop Dean. After all, he said it himself- he doesn't feel anything.

But at least it's out in the open now and he can't pretend everything's ok anymore. Dean will find a way to fix him, make him Sammy again. And until he has his soul back, he's just not Sam to me. He's a shell.

And holy crap my heart is broken about Lisa and Dean. I don't want it to be over between them. :( And Dean...dammit. "I'm not a father, I'm a killer." Oh Dean...=S

Bobby's confessions? Freakin' HI-larious!

And Cas...what the hell is going on with him? "Certain regrettable things"? What has he been up to? I swear, everybody's gone to hell in a handbasket without Dean around to remind them what being human is about- and why it's a good thing to be human.

Holly crap...
Oh dean my dean POOR dean *cries* :"(
he so couldn'y handle that STUPID truth.. ok what lisa said was FREAKIN'STUPID..i've Never Liked her.. and SAM?? Really?? why on Earth Didn't you said the truth the minute Dean Asked you. you left him hoping over some Lies :"(
oOooh Dean "im not a father, im a killer" ?<?< NOT HE'S NOT poor Baby..im Heart broken... Cas totally
pissed me OFF but then after he said he wanted to help him im like ahh CAS :D..

i can't wait to see old sammy BACK... :)

LOL@Bobby xD.. i just want things to be ok between them x'(

just amazingly epic episode! I think you guys have said it all and now that we know what's wrong with him ('cause of the next episode promo) the big question is where is Sam's soul and who has it ?! ;) can't wait to find out :D

Best ep so far this season. What an emotional roller coaster!

1. Poor Dean! Maybe if he'd just tell Lisa what happened, she'd be more understanding. What, he thinks she won't believe him or something? After all she's seen?

2. Bobby's first girlfriend was a- what? He get pedicures? And likes Tori Spelling? Oh, Bobby, you're full of surprises!

3. Ok, so from the promo, it looks like Cas can perform some kind of test to see if Sam still has a soul, so why didn't he do that before?

4. There's still hope! If Sam knows something's wrong, and is scared of himself, and is begging Dean for help, then there's still hope for him! He's still alive somewhere, we just have to find him!

5. I disagree with you guys about the beating. Sam deserved it, and what's more, he NEEDED it. After everything he's done to Dean, and Bobby, and Cas, and everyone else he's come in contact with, he needs to get his head on straight, and if that means Dean has to beat it into him, so be it. This is one time I didn't mind Dean beating the hell out of Sam. (Ugh- pardon the expression.)

One thing I would've liked: Dean could have at least checked Sam's pulse after the beating, just to make me feel better.

I cried really hard in that episode... about Dean and about Sam... Isn't it ridiculus how much a TV show is affecting me???

gah this episode!...i almost cried because of the conversation between dean and lisa...i really hope that is not the end for them.
You could tell how much loosing her and ben hurt dean.

i do feel bad for sam as well though...it's not really his fault he doesn't feel anything, but for all the pain dean has gone through in the last two episodes it makes it a little hard for me to just easily excuse his behavior...and maybe with dean watching everything he does then sam can bring back some of the person he was before.

i really wonder what happened to sam in hell...because he wasn't down there as long as dean was, and dean was a wreck (rightly so) after hell but what could have possibly happened to sam for him to loose his soul that quickly?

i always battle with who is the stronger person, sam or dean, my bias always wants me to say dean because out of all the characters he truly has been through the worst, and a lot of other characters seem to rely on him in one way or another. however on the other hand i see how much strength sam had in taking over control from lu, and constantly fighting demon's when their blood was his addiction. my point being is that for a while i felt like if the tables where turned and sam was in hell, that he would have broken sooner than dean did, but with the last few episodes of season 5 i started thinking maybe he could have lasted as long as dean did but i never thought that he could withstand more than dean. i came to the conclusion that their strength is in different areas but equally as strong. so with sam most likely breaking in hell, what could have possibly been done 2 him in such a short amount of time or him to loose himself like that?

@shomill, I think Dean didn't tell Lisa the truth about what was happening because he doesn't really think it's a valid excuse. He endangered her and Ben- to him that's the bottom line. A part of him wants to stay with Lisa but another part of him wants to protect her from his life. He doesn't think he deserves to have a relationship with her, so I think by not giving her the whole story he was sabotaging himself. Maybe deliberately, maybe subconsciously.

i don't like what they are making Sammy into this season. he doesn't have his soul...i hope he gets it back soon so i don't stop watching.

Why was this episode awesome?

"Why am I telling you? Maybe because you're my favorite."

I didn't LOVE it, but I think it was great!! I really liked it ;)

i like when when that truth god - was like no your not your lieing - how can you lie to me - but it was crazy when Dean was like '' i was going to kill him in his sleep - so crazy - ''