Your absolutely right.

What it ultimately boils down to for Guy is acceptance. All he ever wanted was to be accepted, and loved by someone whether it be the sheriff (father figure) or Marian (soulmate) his dire need for this became the downfall of their love, because unlike Marian or the sheriff, Guy had NO ONE. The sheriff knew this and he exploited the hell out of it by dangling a false sense of 'fathers approval' to get Guy to do some unspeakably horrible things that he wanted, but rather not get his hands dirty with.

Guy never wanted to be the 'bad guy' at all. He was torn between his duty (as a human puppet) and doing what he really thought was right, all the while being manipulated and lied to from both sides. I think thats enough to make anyone have a mental meltdown.

your so right

guy is not the bad guy, he was raised badly. he was always the one who got in trouble and robin would get the glory. of course he would grow up to hate him because he has lived through it and why stop now. then he met marian who he instantly fell in love with and he was so please that he had something robin didn't but he was so focused on how he had this possession that she completely moved on and found robin. and then it all ended with a sad and upsetting ending when he killed marian. how could she have done that i mean come on is so frickin sexy!!!!!!!!!!