Diese Frage beantworten

Percy Jackson vs Harry Potter Frage

Who do Du all like better - Annabeth Chase oder Hermione Granger?

*
ANNABETH CHASE!!!
empousa1robo posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
Annabeth !!!!!
lindalmc97 posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
Hermioneeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
GryffindorGamer posted vor 2 Monaten
 harrypotterbest posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
next question »

Percy Jackson vs Harry Potter Antwort

OOOf123 said:
Ahh,I dont like theres someone saying "stupid argument"...Also,please bär with my grammar.Its only my third language

Let's start then,I've been a Fan of both series but I gotta say Annabeth wins this one.

Look,in the PJO series,remember where Morpheus (The God of Dreams) makes all the people in Manhattan sleep? Well,the demigods didn't got affected Von it. Also the time where Kronus tried to stop time? well a bunch of demigods didnt got affected.Silena Beauregard (Aphrodite's daughter) actually mentioned that "Demigods are resistant on magic". ON the Crossover "Demigods and Magicians" Carter and Sadie Kane's magic doesn't work on Percy and Annabeth.

That one fact,Hermione's trump card is out of the way. Hermione is also very cunning but she's only good on long-ranged combats. Annabeth on the other hand is the daughter of the Goddess of Wisdom herself, and as a demigod,she was trained to defend herself since seven.

This is only an opinion based on facts that I know.You can add Mehr information if Du think it is wrong.
select as best answer
posted vor 22 Tagen 
Mich-Annabeth said:
of course Annabeth. She really is much better than Hermione because Annabeth is smarter, younger, Mehr beautiful, and simply, better person =)
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
Anna isn't smarter. Hermione is smarter, because she 'spoke, as usual, as though she had swallowed a textbook.' Beauty and youth don't matter. Hermione was 12 (near) when she started Hogwarts. Emma Watson is also very pretty!
harrypotterbest posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
What makes Du say Annabeth is smarter, younger, Mehr beautiful, and simply a better person? Du DO realize Hermione's a genius, right? Of course, Annabeth is too, so they must be tied. But what about being younger, Mehr beautiful, and better person? The Harry Potter Bücher age and develop the characters throughout each book, so there WAS a time when Hermione was younger. And don't forget, Annabeth is getting older with each book, too. And how do Du mean Mehr beautiful? Sure, Hermione isn't exactly an eyesore at first, but remember her big entrance at the Yule Ball? (There was a Mehr drastic difference in the books.) Hermione was so breathtaking that even Draco Malfoy, THE SCHOOL BULLY, couldn't think of anything bad to say about her. And better person? Hermione relentlessly tried to save all those "poor house-elves". Yeah, maybe disguising hats so the elves would unwillingly free themselves wasn't the best way to go, but her intentions were good. I think both Annabeth and Hermione are equally good people. :)
ArcticWolf posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
Anna-beth, maybe Du should actually try formulating an argument instead of just saying something without evidence. It's getting really annoying!
lucyhu247 posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
Chasing_Dawn said:
Really, I think it's a tie. We all have opinions, I know, but if it came to it, they'd be best friends.

Annabeth is smart girl. She is firece too, faced her share of challenges. (Titans, Hera, intestinally challenged cows) She's pretty, as Percy says. She's one awesome gal.

Hermione, on the other hand, clever and loves learning. She know most all there is to know. To those who say 'She's nothing without a wand'
Du should know that Hermione punched Draco Malfoy in the face, and he crumpled to the floor. 'Nothing' indeed. She is pretty, as well. (Yule ball)

The two are evenly matched. :) Don't hate, apreciate.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
gwendiamond said:
STOP COMPARING THEM!
They're are both equally brilliant and powerful girls. Annabeth is Merida - Legende der Highlands and intelligent, Hermione is too! They're both the main heroines and therefore are both amazing. I can't choose.
Oh and too people who argue over who is better, GROW UP! Stop arguing over two characters. Don't judge people because they like someone better. Just leave them to their opinions.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
i agree!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
m-girl25 posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
m-girl25 said:
To be honest i Liebe them both and they are both abendessen, abendmahl nice. They are both smart and successful. They are beautiful from the inside out! I think they are equal!
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
yessssssssssssssssssssssssssssss
GryffindorGamer posted vor 2 Monaten
Annabeth1997 said:
Annabeth Chase DUH
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
Why?
harrypotterbest posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
I Liebe your answer Annabeth1997!!!
charolet1 posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
that's terrible argument
GryffindorGamer posted vor 2 Monaten
RavenclawPride said:
Damn this was tricky.
In the end, Hermione won.
She is just my Favorit female character in everything, Weiter to Bellatrix.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
God, I hate Bellatrix! Sirius... Dobby... Neville's parents... close to Hermione... *shudder*
harrypotterbest posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
THAT IS SO NOT TRUE
anna-beth posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
ikr
GryffindorGamer posted vor 2 Monaten
Angel-Trix said:
*Annabeth is smarter (Daughter of Athena people! Why don't Du get that?)
*Annabeth helped her Friends too. For some reason, people can only remember Hermione helping Ron and Harry.
*Hermione would be nothing without her wand.

So overall, Annabeth wins!
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
Hermione is a genuis. They're even.
Chasing_Dawn posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
Hermione punched Draco. She's not a weakling.
Chasing_Dawn posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
Pretty sure she can try and learn non verbal and wandless magic; bet Du she can do it.
GryffindorGamer posted vor 2 Monaten
duncylovescourt said:
both i simply cant choose! hermione in my fav charcter in hp adn annabeth is my fav in pj
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
cereberus said:
to easy Annbeth Von far(no effence hp fans) annabeth is smarter cause she is the daughter of athena goddess of freaken wisdom she is hotter i even had a crush on her once and she has a great boyfriend perseus jackson omg annabeth is way better yes yes she is!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
yes i agree what a smart young lad Hey every one this dude is right i realy must meet him
cereberus posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
that's a terrible argument
GryffindorGamer posted vor 2 Monaten
charolet1 said:
Annabeth Von far!!!
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
Athena12345 said:
I think it's annabeth chase because she's the daughter of Athena, the goddess of Wisdom so annabeth must be very wise.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
musiclover2436 said:
Both are really great..
But annabeth is really Merida - Legende der Highlands and smart and so is hermione
But annabeth has gone through a lot and hermione can't fight(physically) which means she is not really helpful without her wand
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
She punched Draco.
Chasing_Dawn posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
Annabeth took a dagger for Percy
pdemz posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
Oh a dagger? Mate she was tortured Von Bellatrix Lestrange! With Crucio and Crucio make a dagger seem like a splinter
GryffindorGamer posted vor 2 Monaten
hahacheckitout said:
ANNABETH! Hermione just uses BOOK KNOWLEDGE. Annabeth uses EXPERIENCE AND BOOK KNOWLEDGE! Annabeth actually tries to think in a scenario but Hermione uses whatever she learned from a book. Memory doesn't mean your smart.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
Hermione has logic. And in the end, I think saving the world is 'experiance'
Chasing_Dawn posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
Not true
anna-beth posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
thinking in a scenario? yeah when she was 12 she did that. when she going to get killed Von the devil's snare!
GryffindorGamer posted vor 2 Monaten
firegirlfiama said:
I like annabeth Mehr but the trio is alaways special to me as its my fav book
select as best answer
 I like annabeth Mehr but the trio is alaways special to me as its my fav book
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
booknerd4622 said:
I don't know who to pick. I guess annabeth. I feel like she is a slightly better hermoine. And don't get mad at that because hermoine is great, it's just I guess annabeth seems better. The reason, this is so hard is because, while annabeth is smart because her mother, hermoine is smart because that is her choice. Annabeth, though though so is hermoine, is also beautiful. I'm pretty sure that's big if the goddess of beauty tells Du so. And for Du guys out there saying that hermoine is still strong without a wand, I'm sorry but but not really, she just hit Draco who I'm pretty sure wasn't prepared. And while hermoine is amazingly brave, annabeth took on a Titan with a broken arm, held up the SKY, and way more. Not to mention running away at seven. I LoVe hermoine, and I'm thinking Rick riordan based Percy and annabeth on Harry and hermoine(I'm all for Ron and hermoine though.) and yes annabeth has flaws aswell, jealous, prideful, annoying, and sometimes a little to smart, I'm just picking annabeth. Also while hemoine is smart, annabeth is smart AND wise, those two words are a big. I could probly go on all Tag about this but I'm sick, and going to the doctors.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
i can see your point! i like them both so much i could not chose.
m-girl25 posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
she went into the ministry on a polyjuice potion, scared that if it didn't work for as long as they were there, she would get the dementors kiss. if she could hold up the sky she probably would
GryffindorGamer posted vor 2 Monaten
rebecaleia said:
She:
select as best answer
 She:
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
anna-beth said:
Annabeth Chase
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
no
GryffindorGamer posted vor 2 Monaten
hermionefan828 said:
hermione
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
yes
GryffindorGamer posted vor 2 Monaten
lucyhu247 said:
It's kind of funny that people are saying that Hermione would be nothing without a wand. Annabeth would 'be nothing' if her mother was not Athena. Annabeth is a demigod and Hermione is a witch. Also, why are people saying a character is better based on looks? That's just vain and stupid. Both Hermione and Annabeth would probably be aghast at hearing they were being judged my that.

The Frage is not who would win in a fight. It's who do Du like better. In my opinion both characters are brave, intelligent and loyal. But, I find that Hermione has Mehr depth and is Mehr of a unique and realistic character. So she is probably my favourite. Probably... As for who would win in a fight, it really depends on the circumstance; either could beat the other. Although the Percy Jackson universe and the Harry Potter universe have different rules and from them to clash wouldn't make sense. Something that is normal in HP might be extremely powerful in PJ and vice versa.

P.s. I hope what I have written makes sense as I tend to be repetitive, have sentence that go for to long and assume that the reader knows every thought I have.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
Someone who understand. FINALLY!
gwendiamond posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
I disagree with your first paragraph. If Du take away Hermione's wand she can still use her wits, but if Du take away Annabeth's mother she wouldn't have anything. If they were in a battle Du would have to take away Hermione's wand and Annabeth's weapons, but still allow them to use their knowledge. I personally can't decide who is better. I think that Annabeth may be smarter, but she is the daughter of Athena after all. Hermione may be nicer at times. They both start off kind of annoying to the main charachter, but end up better as they get older. If they were to meet though, I think that they would be friends, if Annabeth could look past the fact that she was a wizard, and vice versa.
percabeth4ever7 posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
If Du took away Annabeth's mother she wouldn't be alive.... Also she would still be skilled with a messer and extremely brave.
REDROBINFAN posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
yeah i suppose if Du took away annabeth's godliness and hermione's magic skills then they'd be nothing.
GryffindorGamer posted vor 2 Monaten
drbkid21 said:
Well Annabeth because hermoine is just girly and annabeth is opposite

select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
That's what I like, Hermione doesn't have to be a tomboy to be strong. It's stupid how in YA girls have t o be a tomboy. She's original, and Annabeth is just a copy of Hermione.
SabihaObaid posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
Hermione is neither girly nor a tomboy. Du are both wrong! Annabeth is not a copy of Hermione! She is Mehr athletic and prideful they look completely different and Annabeth is also less emotional.
REDROBINFAN posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
I agree with REDROBINFAN
CindieCath posted vor 9 Monaten
*
i get redbrian's point but still, annabeth cries and the reason hermione cries Mehr is because her parents didn't know her before! i bet Du in the philospher's stone she was used to mean comments, its just she had gegeben up entirely on making friends. annabeth is not a tomboy. they both have good points as well as bad.
GryffindorGamer posted vor 2 Monaten
firebolthades12 said:
Annabeth Chase.She's cool and much Mehr smarter than Hermione!She can fight monsters,and what's hermione done?Got passed a stupid potions problem!
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
im sorry but i've met brot smarter than Du
GryffindorGamer posted vor 2 Monaten
SabihaObaid said:
Please, Hermione is the best. Annabeth is the daughter of Athena, it's only natural for her to be smart. Hermione isn't, yet she's as smart as her. Hermione not only cares for her Friends and family, but she cares for others like elves and creatures put aside. All your stupid Kommentare are making me laugh
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
ArcticWolf said:
Hermione. Annabeth doesn't interest me that much, but I actually like Hermione's character.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
hgchgfcgfhc said:
Annabeth is awesome! She at least has combat skills to

select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
Sophiecoo said:
Hermione Granger all the way hands down
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
Hermione11178 said:
Hermione
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
RoxyPotter said:
Actually, i really think Annabeth is just Hermione. I'm not saying she's a "cheap ripp-off" oder anything, they are literally just the same person. And as we all know HP came out WAY before PJ. So every time i'm Lesen PJ and Annabeth is doing something, i just see Hermione. They both are really intelligent, Merida - Legende der Highlands and kinda lonely. Also Percy and Harry are like almost the exact same person. And i mean, look a the first book, almost the same basic story. Boy who doesn't knows anything about his powers goes to place to control his powers, gets best Friends with a girl who is obviously Mehr intelligent than him, needs to get a special, powerful object away from the bad guy who needs that object, to regain his powers....Oh, and there's a three-headed dog. Same story? I thought so too. But yeah, i need to give Hermione that one, she needed to work hard, Anna was just born intelligent. She can't even do anything powerful, but being intelligent. Hermione at least has a wand, but Weiter to that actually can't do Mehr without it. Anyways, sorry, Anna, Hermione won this one.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
Can Du see Hermione holding up the world? I can't, she may be Merida - Legende der Highlands enough but lacks in the physical strength.
REDROBINFAN posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
redrobinfan mate she could, if she used a spell
GryffindorGamer posted vor 2 Monaten
REDROBINFAN said:
I prefer Annabeth (well I prefer PJ in general) but I can see how people would like Hermione better.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
CindieCath said:
Annabeth. I dislike Hermione's personality
select as best answer
posted vor 9 Monaten 
*
annabeth's personality is the american version of hermione's. okay....
GryffindorGamer posted vor 2 Monaten
oro2 said:
Hermione is the best

select as best answer
posted vor 9 Monaten 
GryffindorGamer said:
I know everyone says Annabeth is better but please, Hermione has magic. Everybody says that Annabeth is better physically but can I ask Du a question? Other than her punching Draco, have Du seen her fight? She is a non violent person so we will never really know. And smarts? Hermione does not just have a memory; she knows the best things to do in a situation. Same goes for Annabeth and she reads books; like Hermione she has a thirst for learning.
Physical strength and sword < Magic
End of.
select as best answer
posted vor 2 Monaten 
next question »