cheating is cheating, and I don't wanna rank them.

if you mean lindsey instead of brooke because he ends up engaged to her

this made Brooke the biggest whore and hypocrite!!!

i don't mean lindsey...i meant in the previous seasons..

i agree..this is the worst bcuz she's a hypocrite.

for once there is a choice about Luke cheating Brooke and not only Peyton!!thank you for that!!!Peyton was also to blame for that but for once im choosing Luke just to get clear that its his fault too!!!i also think that Brooke's cheating was terrible too!!!

I could not believe she took the morale high ground after doing something like this!

Lucas shamefully chasing Peyton while with Brooke in season 1 was pretty crappy as well i'd say they where almost even.

The thing is, Peyton got what she deserved.
She had to sit through her punishment.
But it was smooth sailing for Lucas. All he had to get was a smooth break up in which Brooke still told him that she loved him, and then he got Peyton as his second choice.
He was such a sleeze ball.
Now, I have to agree with abs, but The whole brooke/nate thing was so long ago when they were all different, WORSE, people (well not lucas and haley but you know what i'm saying) and they were broken up. Plus, Brooke apologized.
I do think all of them are wrong though. They were petty and immature and I could not have despised them more for trashing relationships and friendships that were so important to them in such a quick grade school way.
thank god that crap is over.... well, atleast i hope.

i think coming from a guy cheating can almost be expected but from your best friend no way its out of order

1treehillfan - it was so long ago and plus Brooke apologized??? So did Peyton....but you didn't seem to forgive her that easily!

SG1-090 peyton doing that to Brooke is worse because she knew Brooke was head over heels in love with Lucas &she did it so many times .Im not trying to say that Brooke is innocent cause what she did was messed up too but Nathan & Peyton were broken up ,they never loved each other && it was a drunken night .You can clearly see Nathan taking advantage of Brooke in that episode .

Here are some of the convo's Leyton had the first time they where together behind Brooke's back:


(Peyton walks by with a friend. Lucas comes out of the locker room and stops her)
LUCAS: Hey, Peyton.
PEYTON: Oh, hey Brooke had to take off early so she said for you to call her.
LUCAS: Okay. You got a sec?
PEYTON: Uh, yeah. Whats up?
LUCAS: I lied. Okay I cant bury what happened between us.
PEYTON: Lucas, Brooke is my best friend. And shes your girlfriend.
LUCAS: I know. But
PEYTON: But nothing. Okay? Thats where were at right now. Its not fair to her to make a big deal out of what happened. It didnt mean anything. Im sorry. (turns to leave)
LUCAS: Peyton. (Pulls her back and kisses her. Then she kisses him back) See? It does mean something.
PEYTON: It cant
LUCAS: But it does.
PEYTON: Lucas, youre dating Brooke.
LUCAS: I know. And shes great. Okay? But, shes not you. Look ever since you came to my room and you told me how you felt about me Ive been hiding with Brooke. Okay? Ive been trying not to get hurt again. I dont want to hide anymore.
PEYTON: Even if we could be together, what makes you think it would work?
LUCAS: Cause I feel it in my heart. Dont you?
PEYTON: Yes. So what are we going to do?

[Peytons house]
(Peyton answers the door)
BROOKE: Hey girly, lets do some damage. (She walks inside leaving Peyton and Lucas alone)
PEYTON: Were going to hell.
LUCAS: Peyton
PEYTON: No honestly we are horrible, rotten people.
BROOKE: (Off Screen) Come on you two, lets go!
PEYTON: Lucas, I dont want to hurt her.
LUCAS: Neither do I. Okay? But weve got to tell her. Tonight.
BROOKE: (Off Screen) Lets go!
(They look at each other then go inside)

[Another part of the library]
(Lucas and Peyton are between the bookshelves talking privately)
PEYTON: This is so wrong. Sneaking around behind Brooke.
LUCAS: Do you think thats part of it?
PEYTON: Part of what?
LUCAS: Us. You know, that this is wrong. Somehow it makes it feel deeper.
PEYTON: Lucas, Brooke and I have been best friends since elementary school. Weve always put our friendship before guys. Do you really think Id risk losing my best friend over a fling? Cause I wouldnt do that.
LUCAS: Okay. Look I dont want to hurt Brooke. And I dont want to come between the two of you. But, I have to be with you. (They start kissing and Haley is watching from behind them)

Also SORRY RoSaiRe226 Brooke WAS NOT being taken advantage of! she was just a slutbag whore who didn't care about sleeping with her best friends ex-boyfriends of 5 minutes who get back together the next day. She made NO attempt to stop.....

I agree with alessandra_28!
I couldn't believe how she could have said all those horrible things to peyton when she slept with nathan! Who's really the backstabbing bitch?!

Peyton's such a bitch !! Hate her .. not that much but .. HATE HER !!