because he was with Brooke but Nathan is a dick for not firing Carries ass!

Lucas is starting to realize what he wrote himself "..we'd always been meant for each other and every instinct to the contrary had simply been a denial of the following truth: I was now and always would be in love with Peyton Sawyer" :D <3
Nathan should really have fired carrie !

when he was with brooke he was a diick but when he kissed peyton when he was going out with lindsey that was great but i hated nathan kissing carrie

Nathan DIDN`T kiss Carrie.. Carrie kissed Nathan!!!
But I really think he should fired her and tell Haley.. But he didn`t kiss her.. Lucas and Peyton both kissed eachother, so he was a dick!! But remember the question was who was more of a dick, and answers: Lucas for kissing Peyton or Nathan kissing Carrie, not Nathan for not fire Carrie.. And Nathan didn`t kiss her!!
;)

yeah but nathan didn't stop carrie either. I think nathan could have resolved the "carrie" problem a lot better than he did. Staring at her naked from his balcony, letting her flirt with him with little objection, and saying nothing when she kissed him. anyhow, I still picked luke cause he actually kissed peyton back. this is the second time he's cheated on his girlfriend(s) without any demonstrated guilt. he acts all high and mighty but he never seems to account for his mistakes; especially when it comes to women, heh.

yeh i no!! he's always on such a moral high horse always telling people how "badly" they're acting when he is always so much worse!

the only reason I had pick this option is because Nathan didn't actually kiss Carrie, she kissed him, he didn't pull away but he didn't kiss back either...and you know it's hard for me to say this but I kinda feel bad for nathan, if he'd just tell haley whats going on....

i think that nate was a dick for not stopping carrie from kissing him and not telling haley and for sort of leading her on by staring at her and flirting with her but luke was a bigger dick because he kissed peyton and lead her to believe they were getting back together to go propose to lindsay with possibly/probably the same ring ASSHOLE!!!! (Just for the record i'm a major leyton fan and an even bigger lucas fan but that was just wrong)

Lucas is being an asshole

zYou know I could go either way on this one.....but Nathan should have kicked her ass out of the house then and there.

the leyton kiss was great, he was a dick for proposing to lindsey afterwards! Nulle02 i agree he wrote the words so he knows deep down he will always be inlove with peyton :)
nathans a dick because he should of told haley as soon as it happened. she cant be that mad - she kissed nathan but nathan didnt push her away either. nathan knows hes in the wrong !

nathen didn't kiss the nanny she kissed him he should have kicked her ass out but he was being a dick and didn't say anything he just lead her on not knowing she would end up stalking him and stealing his kid but I picked lucas 'cause he kissed peyton and then he PROPOSES to Lindsey that was so mean he was being a big fat hudge dick i was somad at him 4 that!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!! urg i still love lucas but if he dosent chandge his act soon i am so over him UUGG!!! he is such a dick people!!!

Carrie kissed Nathan not the other way around.
The part that made him a dick was not telling Haley
Lucas kissed Peyton back and then to make up for it he proposes?
Hes such a dick

^agreed

Nathan didn't really kissed Carrie