They didnt really forget her birthday, but i hated how it was done with her watching leyton being together. UGH. so sad and makes me angry.

At least Haley had a happy ending, while Brooke was so miserable during her bday.

they did not forget Brooke`s birthday and I didn`t feel sorry for Haley cause she got it all perfect in the end again.

yeah.
most people forget Brooke's birthday , like her parents and Rachel :P
and I know what you mean but NO ONE gave her a present or something... so I felt sorry for her

I know it wasn't technically "forgotten", but nobody really acknowledged it accept for Peyton and even still, nothing was done for her.

Haley got her happy ending.. but Brooke just stayed rly sad :/

^ I agree with most of you, guys.

Yeah, they didn't exactly forget her birthday, but she thought the worst and well, I felt really sorry for her.

Haley's birthday wasn't exactly forgotten either...

Nathan certainly didnt forget Haley's bday and in ended on a good note, kisses on the table and a new car? Sounds good to me :)

Brooke wasnt forgotten more like neglected. They knew it was her bday and they did nothing. They went to the store but considering the circumstances, Peyton should have gone to her, not expected it to work the other way.

aww i felt soo bad for her, her birthday wasnt forgotten but it wasnt acknowledged by her so called friends either. and she never got her happy ending like haley did. poor b.davis <3

haley got a happy ending and even though brooke's wasn't forgotten it was still sad how no one made a big deal about her turning 18. but i felt bad for haley cuz her sis and jamie forgot... and i get the point was for her bday to be forgotten, but not ONE of her many siblings or her parents, not even leyton could call or text her happy bday? i wld think they her family and def lucas would at least say happy bday somehow. lucas remembers jamies but can't remember haley's?

Oh for sure. ='[
Haley got a happy ending, Brooke was miserable all day. </3

Okay, it was a little rough how NOBODY at all remembered Hales' birthday...not even after having a look at her ID xD
But Brooke was all alone during the whole day, she had to see her former best friend with her former boyfriend and the whole day just sucked for her =/
And, like you said, Hales got a happy ending ( =

Birthdays are not given great importance in OTH. Talking about S4 Brooke, nobody forgot her birthday. Usually she pass it with Peyton but she CUT her out. Peyton sent Lucas to the store but she never showed up until Leyton went away & Brooke happened to be there. Let's call it twist of faith, it sucks but ultimately Brooke did this to herself.