Hard one... I loved Hales in both these seasons.

great season for Haley

i found myself seriously wanting to smack her several times throughout s3

My fav season! Everyone was good there!:)
Even Peyton

Damn this was hard! xD
I loved her in season 3 so much, but I also loveeeddd her preganancy sotryline in season 4! They were both such good seasons for her and Nathan! <33

i like her in both, but pregnant haley wins. :)

She bugged me in some parts of season three.

Love her in this season <33

She's the same to me in these 2 seasons. I didn't hate or dislike her in either and neither is my favorite season for her.(s1:)

i loved Haley in sesaon 3, she realised what she wanted outta life and she started to get it, Nathan, and she started to get Naley back together(L), her and Lucas regained their friendshipp, and we had some great Baley scenes too.
She was also great though in season 4, with Nathan and Jamie (:

Partly because i prefer S3 to S4, but i just found Haley to be slightly more enjoyable in S3.

It was everyone's best season finally because in this season I liked her more than in the others.

Hard one. But I love her when she's pregnant...soooo cute!!! <3 And she's such a badass (the Rachel bitch slap...Go, Haley! ^^)

Pregnant Haley is my favorite!!!

i loved her in s3. her best tied with s1. everyone was the best in s3. lol but i just loved her and how she was trying soo hard to get nathan back and her and brooke as roomates was adorbale and hilarious. lol

I loved her in both.

eeekk both ! my 2 faves :)

BOTH!