Mostly the guys.
They're sturdry, they never cry.
So it's most heartbreaking when they cry especially Nathan.
But I cry everytime someone cries! LOL :p

I only cry when Brooke cries lol it's so heartbreaking to see her sad because she's always this happy girl who helps other people when they need it. And it's just REALLY hard to see her sad.

Nathan is a pretty strong character, so when he cries it's terrible.

Brooke's is bad too but it just seems like she has constant heartbreak, so it's pretty ordinary for her to start crying. Nathan, not so much.

I agree with you sarabeara.
It's more rare that you see Nathan cry than Brooke

^ totally agree. I picked Peyton at first, because normally she's the only one that actually makes me cry. But I had to change my pick to Nathan, because like you guys said, we see the girls cry all the time... So it does kind of hit you harder when one of the guys cry. I would have picked Chad, but I think James is a better actor and is more convincing when it comes to crying

exactly!

Brooke and Peyton!!

Brooke can make me cry in lot of emotional scenes but Peyton too!

Well I've cried when:
Peyton cried over Jake-end of season 2
Nathan cried over Haley when she had the accident.
Lucas cried over Peyton in season 6.
Haley cried when Nathan jumped from the bridge.
All heartbreking.

i ALWAYS cry when Brooke cries, she makes it feel so real.

All of them are awesome! But my fav is Hales like I said before.

i ALWAYS cry when Brooke cries, she makes it feel so real. - I feel so , too !

But I pick Nathan , because he don't cry everyday , but this one time .. this was sooo real ! I love this scene .. I had to cry when I watch this (:

This is very hard to choose, i think it's a tie between Nathan and Brooke..
Brooke is AMAZING on vulnerable moments, but i have to pick Nathan on this one, because like it was already said, he doesn't cry much. Of the main five, he's the character who cries less. So when he does.. You know it's something big.

I think James is awesome on crying <3
Not only on sad moments like 4.09, but also in 6.24 when he was telling Haley that he got to the NBA, he had tears in his eyes. *.*

Oh yeah, I cried in 6x24 too cause I was happy for them! :D

Brooke and Peyton mostly!

Peyton. and Lucas.

Brooke and Nathan def!

except the peytons crying scenes from s2 were pretty heartbraking too. ohh and nates.

At first, I picked Brooke, because when she cries I cry.
But like most of you said, the guys hardly ever cry. So seeing Nathan cry is something really big.

All of them are heartbreaking except for Lucas!! Its just weird when he "tries" to cry! But anyways when Nathan cries, its always because something bad happened to his family and I m a total; Nlaey fan so when he crisI cry with him because I'm really atached to this one family and it breaks my heart when any one of them cries!!

Peyton is a great crier, I amlost always cry when she does, which means I cry a lot. lol

But when Lucas told his mom about his HCM and he cried, my heart broke. it was so sad

^ Lol, i started laughting at that scene. =/ Not because i'm sadic (LOL), but Chad's crying made me laugh. =/ lol
I think he's MUCH better now, when he cried in 6x17 was really heart-breaking.

They're all heartbreaking though! <33

Whenever Nathan, Lucas or Brooke cries I cry. Peyton makes me cry too, but I guess cause so much crap happens to her I kind of get used to her being upset.

Tied with Brooke.

I picked nathan. James lafferty is such a great actor and when he cries my heart always breaks. When Haley gets hit by dante in season 4 and nathan is in the hospital crying it is so so so so sad. Also when Haley cries when nathan jumps off the bridge I cry too and when she is crying right after they get
Married an d is organizing their CDs and she realizes theyvhave nothing in commmon. And when luke told his mom Brooke was pregnant in season 1 and she slaps him and he starts to cry that is really good acting. And sophia bush is really great at being Brooke but Brooke cries a lot. She is. A very emotional character and I cry when she cries it just hitsbme harder when nathan cries.

I cry evertime someone cries in OTH, I'm a sap!
I hate when Lucas cries it is so heartbreaking
I also agree about the Naley NBA scene that absolutely made me cry

Brooke too!! In season 5 Haley's crying scenes were really amazing. When the guys cry, it just seems too fake for me to get into :(

She always makes me cry! & Peyton, sometimes.

altho Nathans scene was the most heartbreaking:'(

Oh God, when Sophia cries, I cry! Next would have to be Peyton & Nathan for sure!