Hilarie looks great in all the seasons in my opinion, but if I had to pick I think season 6 because I really like her hair that way and it just shines. ;)

i love Hilaire Burton and i think shes soo cute, but i dont really like her hair this season, i dnt like how the roots are really black and then it turns to a dirty blonde lol idk im just not a fan. but i loved her hair in s2 she looked soo cute.

Or 4

2, 3 and 6! :)
i loved her curly hair in season 2.. and she was with jake and they make SUCH a pretty couple. so that made her even prettier <3 :D

1, 3, 5 and 6

Don't get me started on the radioactive blonde giant ringlets in season two.

But these are all REALLY pretty icons.

1, 4, 5, and 6

She was also really pretty in season 3

She was definately prettiest in season six.
Then...
s1, s4, s3, s5, s2
Although, In seasons 2 and 5, her look was really similar.

i hated her hair in season 1...i like season three too

when she is happy she always pretty

all seasons

Like ale said shes gorgeous all seasons but I reckon she's stunning this season :)

I agree with kristine95!

I'm not crazy with her bangs but I love how goldilocks she looks in s2...and she's with Jake so she looks extra happy

I also hink she was pretty in season 2 too. I kinda liked her with curly hair. But season 4 she was best.

All seasons!Except maybe S5 begginings!

she looks gorgeous in all seasons i really liked her hair in s3 and s4!!!!! but she looks stunning in s6 x

i loved her in season 1, her hair was really pretty!

Season 1 and 2 :) Season 6 is SOOO UGLY!!

I think the only season I wasn't crazy about her looks in was s5.

she always looks great:)

i think shes not pretty at all in any season expect 3, she actually looked decent then. in season 1 also she was cute with chubby cheeks but most of the times shes not at all pretty (repetitive but i'm trying to be nice :P), big bug eyes, body of a 10 year old boy, pimples around mouth, big pores, etc.

SHE was pretty and gorgeous,and stunning in all seasons.but i think she looks the best now in 6 season,after is,1 season i love her with big curly hair..xd,next season 3,4,5 and 2

She's always pretty :)

DO YOU HAVE TO BE SOO FREKING RUDE? *MADI-GIRLXO*
GODD IF YOUR GONNA BE SUCH A BITCH, DONT COMMENT AT ALL!!
AND WHAT SHOW DO YOU WATCH POST MAN PAT?

"body of a 10 year old boy"..yeah..10-YEAR-OLD boys would wish to be SO tall and have those amazing legs..as you wish too! XDD I'm wondering If you've really ever seeing her!

^ LMAOO G!

In the begginning of season 1 I didn't think she was all that pretty but in the middle-towards the end she was very beautiful. I hated her curls in season 2, but she was still pretty (since we aren't talking just about hair) and in season 3 I thinks she looked AMAZING (second favorite), season 5 she wasn't so hot and season 6 she is OKAY but her hair reminds me of cardboard it's so stiff... but season 4 she was simply BEAUTIFUL. :)
I loved her short curly hair, except like not insane curls like in seaosn 2, and not to mention she smiled more, and just all together she seemed prettier, and brighter.

madi-girlxo, are you even WATCHING any of her scenes? First of all, you must have pretty great sight if you can see her pores on a little TV screen?
Pimples around the mouth? Yeah... not seeing them. Maybe you're just projecting your own insecurities on Hilarie Burton. Food for thought. XD

GO Sarah! So true what you said..I mean If you don't like her just DON'T ANSWER..we don't need your judgemental comment madi-girlxo..XDDD

Wow. Okay, that's a horrible thing to say about Peyton, madi-girlxo. She is a very beautiful women and it's not right to bash her like that.

^ AWW YOUR SO SWEET! ♥
LMAO

Mmmkay madi-girlxo you fucking man! We had like probably the longest streak of fake ass accounts not commenting until your gross ass came along. Why do all the fucking haters have to be Brucasers? You`re def a little fat midget who wished you looked like Peyton! She looks like a model and you have a crush on her you creature.

EWWW.

GO MYRA!

LMAO MRYA YOU KICK ASS!

OMG! ♥

We're gonna get in trouble
We're gonna start a fight
nanananana
We're gonna start a fight

HIL IS GORGEOUS. WHAT SHOW R U WATCHING MADI-GIRLXO!?

Hil is just gorgeous..by far the most beautiful on the show (IMO) the only season that i really don't think she is pretty is s2 and even then she isn't ugly. She is pretty in season 1 but i realllllly started LOVING her in s3, s4, s5, and s6 <3 ESPECIALLY SEASON 6.

every season of course, but I don't like season 1's hair cut...

hunny those pimples around mouth are herpes!

YOU WOULD KNOW!

you are so gross wannabe Myra
seriously get a life soon instead of creating fake accounts to insult someone you dont even know and talk shit about a tv character.

Kathiriaeatsass- That was REALLY rude. Like REALLY rude... and just hideously mean. Not to mention racist. I think you need to just calm down.

Alice that person needs to leave...check at her/his profile.
It's totally a fake account.
Everyone should report her/him

^^ Yeah we should probably report her for offensive content.
Because THAT (what she said) is the one crap thing about this site.

Already reported.
Alice, I'm sorry your pick turned into a ... this.

^^ Ha. It's alright... it's not your fault ;)
These things are prone to this kind of crap... it's the risk you take when you make a pick lol.
Anyways, thanks for the apology (even though its not your fault) and I just hope she gets kicked off!
I mean have you seen her profile???
Racist!

Ok instead of yellling at KEA which i really want to do i'll answer the pick.
Season 3 she looked GREAT. i loved her hair, face, and whole look.
Next is season 4, I loved how her hair grew out, and she looked gorgeous especially in her first (white) prom dress!
Season 2 she was looked amazing when she was smiley happy and I actually loved her hair!
Season 5 I liked her hair more, and I liked to see a more older-looking Peyton.
Season 6 she looks great smiling but her hair is not so hot, IMO.
Season 1 I don't really like her look too much. Her hair was okay and her face was a little wide or something.
But she is so beautiful I am insanely jealous! Lol.

I know right!

Not only is she flat out bashing a member, but somehow she managed to do it all by being recist, insulting a character, and insulting us "seytoners"

She needs to get kicked off this site, and get some help!

^^ Agreed.
Those kinds of people are so disgusting.

And Molly lol I pretty much agree with all you said :)

I don't really think Peyton is a looker myself but the straight bob was definitely her best look! [=

she has always been pretty..
so that's why i'm taking season 1

But she's really pretty in the icon you used for s4. :)

she always looks so pretty.. I love how mature and elegant she looks in the second half of season 6.. and she looks so pretty to in season 3.. I like her hair in season 5.. not in the beginning tho.. and then season 4.. the best curly hair style for her.. season 1 .. and I don't really like the hair style in season 2.. well.. she still looks so pretty tho..

she always looked stunning :)

To be honest I don't like her hair being flat and short like in season 3. In the other seasons I Think she was beatiful, but she was so cute in season one, I liked especially her hair

I love her in all season. My personal favourites are S6 & S3