What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

Harry Potter Who's employment do Du think was Mehr of a waste of money? (considering the amount of his/her appearance)

51 fans picked:
Frances de la Tour - Madame Maxime
Frances de la Tour - Madame Maxime
   33%
Matyelok Gibbs - Muriel
Matyelok Gibbs - Muriel
   16%
Dave Legeno - Greyback
Dave Legeno - Greyback
   14%
David Ryal - Dodge
David Ryal - Dodge
   12%
none they shouldve had Mehr
none they shouldve had Mehr
   8%
(added by danielledemeyer)
Helen McCrory
Helen McCrory
   6%
Rade Serbedzija - Gregorowitch
Rade Serbedzija - Gregorowitch
   6%
Michael Byrne - Grindelwald
Michael Byrne - Grindelwald
   4%
George Harris - Kingsley
George Harris - Kingsley
   2%
 delamico posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

10 comments

user photo
I don't think they were a waste of money - the issue is not the ratio between the money / screen time. As long as these actors and actresses played their part well and add value to the story, there is no problem.

Should we consider then the extras (students, Hogwarts staff, passers-by and clients in Diagon Alley, etc) be a waste of money too ? But without them, the scenes would have looked rather empty and liveless. Thing is, we need people that play well and the HP movies showcased many talents. The issue is rather on the screenplay side, where the screenwriter will allow lines and room to an actor/actress to develop fully their characters. Some characters do appear for a minute or two but they can be essential to the plot (see Aunt Muriel or old Bathilda, for example).
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.
 
user photo
Matyelok Gibbs - Muriel
delamico picked Matyelok Gibbs - Muriel:
ANYBODY else could have told those things of Dumbledore to Harry. As the have already changed so many thing about the books. And my point is not the money, that's just a metaphorical expression for how these tiny pop ups actually disturbed me. Because in the books they have time to be characters.. but poor Greyback, too never had a chance to rip somebody apart, Muriel - since we don't even figure out in the bloody movie, who she is - could have been Slughorn who we know from HBP or Kingsley who hasn't have 5 sentences since movie 5. Madame Maxime is just nonsense and it'd have been the least to give Helen McCrory the grabbing Lucius's wrist and suggesting him to hand over his bloody wand as SHE'll be the one saving Harry's guts in part too.. and again: I can't see that coming...
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.
 
user photo
Matyelok Gibbs - Muriel
Narusasu4EVER picked Matyelok Gibbs - Muriel:
The others have more important role than her!!!
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.
 
user photo
Frances de la Tour - Madame...
JAlanaE picked Frances de la Tour - Madame Maxime:
I'm not sure if you're referring to DH1 or to all the movies. I picked only considering DH1 now. Madam Maxime is not even supposed to be there, is she? At least I can't remember her being at the wedding in the book. I didn't mind her being there, but it wasn't necessary.
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.
 
user photo
Matyelok Gibbs - Muriel
Mongoose09 picked Matyelok Gibbs - Muriel:
yeah either her or Maxime. at least we knew who Maxime was, whereas I dont even think it was mentioned that it was even Muriel in the film was it?? (it was obvious if you've read the book, but it still wasnt mentioned) - they could've just had Elphias say her lines or something.
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.
 
user photo
Matyelok Gibbs - Muriel
delamico picked Matyelok Gibbs - Muriel:
I'm referring to DH. :D
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.
last edited Vor mehr als einem Jahr
 
user photo
Dave Legeno - Greyback
hrrypttrfn328 picked Dave Legeno - Greyback:
He was in part one? :)
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.
 
user photo
Matyelok Gibbs - Muriel
delamico picked Matyelok Gibbs - Muriel:
He was. He looked around.. LOL.. what a role..
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.
 
user photo
Dave Legeno - Greyback
moonagedaydream picked Dave Legeno - Greyback:
Greyback goes from being one of the coolest characters in the books to a random background character. I mean, we don't even find out he's a werewolf, do we? At least his replacement is hot... Nick Moran... Scabior... Mmmm <3
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.
 
user photo
Michael Byrne - Grinde- lwald
fishypup picked Michael Byrne - Grindelwald:
Yeah, most or all of them should've been seen more...but I really liked Frances de la Tour as Madame Maxime, even with that miniscule and inconsequential appearance...:/
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.