What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

Harry Potter Well ive gotten alot of complaint's about the Frage did Harry die in the 7th book so now Du can tell me with this pick so what do Du think

90 fans picked:
he dies but he also lives
he dies but he also lives
   63%
he never died
he never died
   16%
harry stays alive
harry stays alive
   14%
Harry died
Harry died
   4%
IDK
IDK
   2%
 kijames posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

12 comments

user photo
he dies but he also lives
ABDCFan- picked he dies but he also lives:
**SPOILER**

Voldemort kills him, but thats only because Harry has a part of his soul in him. Voldemort doesn't know this(i don't think) But i think Harry gets the choice between whether he gets to stay alive or stay dead. He choses life, obvs. And there you go, :)
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.
 
user photo
he never died
NimfaDora picked he never died:
Voldemort kill part of his own soul, not Harry's. It is Voldemort who dies, not Harry.
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.
 
user photo
he dies but he also lives
Faith-Rulz picked he dies but he also lives:
it annoys me where they say harry didnt die, but in a way he did, he was stuck inbetween life and death...thats death in some way...but im glad harry came back too lol
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.
 
user photo
he dies but he also lives
ABDCFan- picked he dies but he also lives:
That's why i said that he could either choose life or death. I'm sure that is what Dumbledore said to him, when Harry met him at the train station when he was between the two? And me too, i'm very glad Harry came back.
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.
 
user photo
he dies but he also lives
Cinders picked he dies but he also lives:
I said it on your quiz question, I'll say it again here - Harry dies in the same way Buffy Summers dies in season one. Even though she was revived, and dead for a minute, it was still a sufficient reason to call a brand new Slayer. Ergo, Buffy really was dead. The same, I think, can be said for Harry. It's never explicitly stated whether he was dead in those moments or not, but he was definitely unconscious, and I'm willing to bet that he wasn't breathing for at least ten seconds from the force of the hit. Also, as Faith-Rulz pointed out, he was in a weird celestial train station, and I'm sure if he wanted to hop the A-Train, he could have.

Also remember that before he regains consciousness, he had to be still enough for Voldemort to believe that he had been killed. It took Narcissa to get close enough to feel his heartbeat to tell that he was alive. But I'm guessing that his chest wasn't moving a noticeable amount, otherwise Voldemort would have noticed that he was breathing.
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.
 
user photo
he dies but he also lives
Mongoose09 picked he dies but he also lives:
Basically everyone above pretty much summed it up for me :)
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.
 
user photo
he dies but he also lives
Mrs-Grint picked he dies but he also lives:
Yeah, same.
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.
 
user photo
he dies but he also lives
volleyblue13 picked he dies but he also lives:
Me too :) Basically, Harry dies because Voldemort's soul was a PART of Harry's soul. So, he died, but then decided to live.
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.
 
user photo
he dies but he also lives
kijames picked he dies but he also lives:
Thank u everyone who has answered
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.
 
user photo
he dies but he also lives
EalasaidWooster picked he dies but he also lives:
It's complicated. :)
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.
 
user photo
he dies but he also lives
Lackson4ever85 picked he dies but he also lives:
kinda weird
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.
 
user photo
he dies but he also lives
k_becca picked he dies but he also lives:
the part of him that was voldemort died, but harry himself stayed alive
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr.