I think thier story is so sweet! but I feel horrible for Snape! :(

At least I hope so!

I think they both loved her a lot but **spoiler** what about his patronus? He's loved her ever since. He watched over her son, helped protect him all these years. He did all those things for her.

But Snape is close, very, very close!

snape felt guilty about lily all his life

Yeah, but James gave up his life so Lily could run!
And Snape called Lily a mudblood...

And you've ^ never said anything you regret in a moment of anger?

Yes, James gave his life for Lily to run, and I commend him for that, I really do. However... Snape gave up his life for her too, and had to live with it for yeeaars. All that time he had to live with unrequited love, knowing that it was his fault he not only alienated the love of his life, but also his best friend, and knowing he was to blame for her death!

James
cause sanpe called her a "Mudblood"

WOW, I'm honestly really surprised that Snape isn't winning. No offence, but usually he wins every freakin' poll. It's actually a breath of fresh air.

But anyway, Snape did love her, but James DIED for her.

snape by far

James died trying to buy her and Harry time to flee.

And really, it's a bit of a moot point, since we don't know if James and Snape would do the same thing as the other did, if their roles were reversed. You can't really use their actions as measures of their love for her.

i hate james he was so mean