yeah i cried so much.. everytime i read it i feel like this...it'so sad... but i cried even Mehr in the part where Dumbledore has already drunk the potio nand Harry keep saying "it's ok sir, don't be afraid,we'll get back and etc" he replied "I'm not worried,Harry. I'm with you". In this sentence i always start crying!!!And the part where the others learn about it, and Hagrid.... They're all so touching..
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
me too!!! i just cant stop myself,i cry so much....but the moment when dumbledore died...i couldnt belive it...i was sad all week...:(((
I never could bring myself to like Dumbledore (no offense to any Dumbledore fans), so I wasn't exactly sad when he died, but I was in complete shock that Snape killed him, because I had staunchly believed from the beginning that Snape was on the good side. When I read it, I actually yelled at the book "NO! What the freak are Du doing, Snape?!" :D I wasn't too upset that Dumbledore died, but I was super upset that Snape was the one to kill him.
Yes, I sobbed. I thought it was really sad the way he died and the fact that Harry could do nothing to stop it. Dumbledore's death was something I didn't want to believe because he was always the one to protect others. With him gone, there was a huge void, I rate.
Now before Du all jump on me, cussing me out and such, I DO have reasons for not liking Dumbledore (since, Du know, I DON'T like him)
In short, he's always been too manipulative, using Harry and Severus like pawns in a chess game, just for his own selfish devices. I was always turned off Von his manipulations, his slogan 'for the greater good', and his insgesamt 'perfect, grandfatherly professor' facade.
It all just seemed too fake.
I will admit, though, that JK would kill him off in the 6th book and not the 7th.
I don't know, maybe i'm just Lesen into this series a bit much, but it's honestly how I feel, and I'd appreciate it if people don't jump all over me for it. Du respect my opinion, I'll respect yours.
Thank you.
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
Actually, I kinda felt the same about Dumbledore Von the end of the fifth book. But then he died and was still sad.
yeah, me too... maybe because the movie is ACTED, Du know, and no matter how good it is, it just does not compare with imagination and the feeling Du get when Du read the story yourself...
I didn't cry. I don't usually cry over books, though. I cried over New Moon, and I think for when Harry broke up with Ginny. Kind of. LOL. I'm an unemotional, coldhearted soul. As if!!! (Puh-lease)
i literally ALWAYS cry, when i read that part! i honestly think that dumbeldore was my favourite character, because he was always so calm, and protective. i always try not to cry, but i cant ever stop myself........ its way to sad.
No, I was stunned Von what Snape did though. My mind was working overtime and I kept thinking "this had not happened, he is not evil, there must be something Mehr to it". I did cry watching the movie though, but I cried for Snape, not Dumbledore. After Lesen the last book I am not sure I even like Dumbledore that much.
I didn't but it is really hard to beleive that someone so loving, so caring, so greatful and so Merida - Legende der Highlands and strong etc. could die! I felt so many emotions, sorrow, rage because of the betrayel, shock, and I was especially confused...
yes yes YES I did but i think it ws all about snape and draco going bad (I now snape isnt bad)but still sad about dumledour . Du have to Liebe the gay wise old man
To be entirely truthful, I cried for a few days. Dumbledore was never one of my Favorit characters - I liked him, but I wasn't close to him. But JKR wove a lot of emotion into that. We became close to Dumbledore along with Harry and then we Lost him. I also cried because I didn't want to believe Snape was evil, and I trusted him, but I didn't see any way out. The secrets JKR created are masterfully hidden! I had no CLUE about Snape and Dumbledore's past! The lies Snape told Bellatrix at the beginning of HBP were really weak, but the death scene was so strong, Du have a terrible time keeping your faith.
When I read the book, yeah. I cried like mad... I was alone in the house and I just started crying, and I was Lesen in the living room... And then my brother came in and he was like, O_o. LOL now that I think of it, it was prettey wiered~ But I couldn't help myself, I was just so shocked because, well, it's Dumbledore! He helped Harry so much, I couldn't understand how he will even survive without him...
When I was Lesen HBP we were painting the house and my parents bett was in the living room. Well, I was lying down and I read that Snape told Avada Kedavra and I was crying for half an hour. I remember I was trying to calm but whenever I was trying to read the Weiter page tears were coming up again. When I finally managed to continue I read that Hargid's house was on feuer and than Fang was in and I started crying again. After that first time, when I read HBP I don't cry when he dies, I cry at his funeral... Great wizard... RIP.
i was gutted!!! i didnt have much faith in harry then and i thought that everyone was doomed because dumbledore was the only one voldemort ever feard!!! :(
in the book i absolutely balled my eyes out and i balled in the film too. Ive seen the film 9 times and cried each time. its embarrassing to watch it with Friends because i just cry.
No way i would cry for him!!!When i read it i was like YAY HE DIED!!!!And in the movie i was as happy as Bellatrix and i was laughing for what she was doing after snape killed him!!!
uh of course! dumbledore was the funniest of all old men. i wondered what the 7th book would have been like if he would have been alive. P.S. I cried when all the good characters died! tonks, lupin, fred, sirius, mady-eye moody, DOBBY!
In the book-no, but in the movie-yes. But the first time i ever cried while Lesen a book was when I read Snape's tale, well, the 'Prince's Tale'-the chapter in the deathly hallows.
No. Dumbledore was the only character that I didn't cry over. Yes, JK put a lot of powerful emotion into that scene, I won't deny it. But I'm not a Dumbledore Fan and it didn't make me cry.
The movie slaughtered that scene. In the book, it tugged my herz strings a little, but the movie did nothing for me.
No..I was Mehr in Shock. AS I was when Sirius Died. But Ironically I cried when their murderers died. Im effed up-noo lights on upstairs what so ever.- EEH HE HE!
to a quite large degree of shame, i technically cried. i have this habit of laughing at sad oder bad parts so hard that i cry. and thats what happened when dumbledore died. like yesterday, when i got kicked in the head Von a horse. i was brushing his front LEFT leg, and a fly was bothering that leg, so he lifted his front RIGHT leg to swat at it, when it promptly conked my left temple nicely. i ended up having to dunk my head in a bucket of cold water, i got hiccups and was crying…and…and…DUMBLEDORE!
Not really... I did cry when I watched it a Sekunde time after finishing the Bücher and learning why Snape did what he did.. but I was crying for Snape and the awful things he's had to do, not for Dumbledore.
