Diese Frage beantworten

Critical Analysis of Twilight Frage

My Friends sagte this and made me mad!

Ok so i was waiting forever to read "The Lovely Bones" and i finally got it! i was so happy i told my Friends and this is what they said! That looks stupid I saw the Vorschau for it. Yeah, I actually saw it it's stupid. Yeah, Twilight is sooo much better. Um no it's not. Yeah it is its about Liebe and is dramatic and full of action, I Liebe action its so awesome!!
ok so let's see "The Lovely Bones" isn't about love? Yeah a father not giving up on his daughters murder case after several years isn't love, but a girl going gaga over a "hot" guy who sparkles is? TLB isn't dramatic? Yeah, so a family having to deal with death of a child isn't dramatic, but a girl having to chose over a sparkly vampire oder a werewolf with anger problems is? If i Debatte anymore i might have get violent!
So please post ur debate/opinions on wat my Friends had to say!
 GinnyXHarryluv posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
next question »

Critical Analysis of Twilight Antwort

mandapanda said:
I think the Lovely Bones and Twilight are completely different. They can't really be compared.

The Lovely Bones is based on the father not giving up on his daughter's case. It is love. But it's a fatherly love.

Twilight has to do with two teenagers falling in love. The "obsessive" Liebe where the other person appeals to Du due to attraction. Du see each other, Du talk, Du court, Du fall in love.

These two can't really be compared in my opinion. And can I say something? It's been...too long since I have debated with anyone. Sometimes, it's hard to deal with those types of Fans that can't see eye to eye oder at least be objective. But same thing goes to the antis.

Both Fans and non-fans of the Twilight series have their kooks. I wouldn't dwell on it though. In the end, it's all fiction. People take from Bücher what they will, whether Du find the message good oder bad in your opinion. But people take from Bücher what they will due to what they have experienced.

Maybe that's not the case for your friends, but remember, not all Twilight Fans are like this.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
nicely put :]
teamsalvatore98 posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
heiiii..I absolutely AGREEEEEEEEE
manjusang posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
i totally. agree they are 2 different book. its like comparing a papagei to a chair (random ;)) the Schreiben is different, the storyline, everything is different!
alisonfaith297 posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
tdafan121 said:
What. The. Hades.

I know insane Twi-hards who should be detained, but insulting a book that actually has a good, dramatic, climactic plot is cold. I hate when those people who Liebe the plotless void with an apfel, apple on the cover bash good Bücher like Harry Potter and Percy Jackson. It makes me sick.
Du can tell your friend that The Lovely Bones has Mehr plot than all four Twilight Bücher plus Meyer's novella combined has and to try Lesen the Bücher instead of watching movie preivews.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
Darkshine said:
She did what?
Oh my gosh.
My best friend sagte Meyer is the best writer in the world, she sagte she wrote the best series ever, she insulted HP and PJO at least 5 times in every sentence but this is a scandal!
Lovely Bones can not be compared to Twi-crap!
I am sorry for over-reacting but I am really angry now.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
She insulted PJO? Rawr. PJO rocks.
tdafan121 posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
Noooooooo. May she go to Tartarus.
GemonkDruid posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
samuraibond005 said:
People have their different opinions but honestly I think that your friend was doing no Mehr than attacking the book Du spent so long to read. I can't say too much but I can say this, there is no need to attack each others opinions oder get into an argument that could ruin the friendship. I'm sure nether of Du would like that.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
XChatterbox14x said:
People have the right to voice thier own opinions but i can understand how Du feel if they voiced thier Ansichten in that childish "It is stupid, omg i Liebe twlight" sort of manner, if they are constructive and aren't rude then thier argument is reasonable, if it's mean well it's mean and they shouldn't be like that. I think Du shouldn't really bring up the Debatte again, as i don't think you'll be able to persuade them, but if they say thier opinions about the book (and not in a constructive way) then Du give them your opinions about twilight! Can i just say well done for bieng intelligent and Lesen a book other than the vampire teenage genre! i mean there's nothing wrong with Lesen vampire teenage genre, but there is when Du are obsessed with it, and Du disagree wth everything else :) Hope this helps :D x
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
ros59 said:
I agree,but I like Twilight,and The lovley Bones has Mehr Liebe than twilight
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
cassie-1-2-3 said:
I think Du should have accepted that she has a different opinion than you, and explain calmly to her that she should do the same, then Bewegen on.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
LackingLogic said:
The Lovely Bones has a stronger and Mehr powerful message of Liebe than Twilight could ever dream of having. Even if Twilight was a good and well written series, it would still lose. Family Liebe beats out obsessive teenage crush Liebe any day.

select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
-Grace- said:
It was incorrect of them to say that Twilight is better. No book is inherently better oder worse than any other. They can be better oder worse from a literary perspective, but enjoyment of a story is too subjective to be broken down into "objectively better" and "objectively worse" :)

I Liebe Twilight, but I didn't like The Lovely Bones. That doesn't mean Twilight is better, it just means that I enjoyed it more. That's not the same at all! :) You're Friends weren't quite right.
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
next question »