Diese Frage beantworten

Critical Analysis of Twilight Frage

*Possible spoilers* SO have Du read the Bree Tanner book? Where does it rank amongst the series?

For those who aren't willing to read it themselves (e.g. ME!), oder those who aren't sure whether they will read it oder not, oder those who have and would like to discuss, what did Du think? Was it any good? Although I have no intention of Lesen it myself, I'd still like the scoop. Just out helpless CAT curiosity. But Du do think it's good, please, feel free to change my mind. :)
*
Thanks for making this question. I read the summary and it sounded awesome compared to the other books.
MadamOcta13 posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
 snoznoodle posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
next question »

Critical Analysis of Twilight Antwort

Dearheart said:
I was bored. I was curious. And boredom and curiosity is a deadly combination that often gets me into trouble. xD I can't believe I did it, but I did. I read Bree Tanner.

Even Mehr unbelievable...it wasn't as bad as I thought it would be. In fact, parts of it were actually pretty...good. Granted, most of it was sort of boring and there wasn't much of a plot (as usual), but it was still a step up from the other books, I think. If the whole Twilight series had been like this, I probably wouldn't hate it as much.

Of course, it helped a LOT that Bree was a stronger character and that it wasn't from Mary Su--*cough* I mean, Bella's POV. The purple prose, the whining, the going on and on how godlike Mr. Sparklepants was, etc...most, if not all of that was gone.

Lesen this makes me wish that the whole series had been about Bree and her gang oder the newborns/Vultori in general, honestly. Way Mehr interesting and bloody and vampire-ish (though that's not saying a whole lot when it comes to Twilight, lol). I'm not really into vampires, let alone Meyerpires, but it was still neat to see her struggles and experiences as a "newborn". And seeing the Cullens through her eyes helped me appreciate them a little more. Here she is, a Zufällig vampire kid who's known hardly anything but survival and human blood and satisfying her hunger for it...meeting these crazy people who've actually learned to rise above all that. It's mind-boggling to her, and it was neat to explore that a little.

But the VERY BEST PART of the whole thing was Bree - oder rather, SMeyer - referring to her own so-called Vampire as "walking disco balls". That alone made the whole thing worth Lesen for me. xDDD

Of course, there just HAD to be a big insta-fall-in-love/sparkly scene (among other ridiculous stuff, aka the typical Mary Sue-isms and the whole secret-ninja-BFF-club thing) in it to remind me that this was still Twilight stuff I was reading. It was utterly lulzy. Here's the excerpt. Read at your own risk.

Everything blazed in the color and light shining off of us.

"Wow," I muttered.

Diego grinned at me, his face beautiful with light, and suddenly, with a deep lurch in my stomach, I realized that the whole BFF thing was way off the mark. For me, anyway. It was just that fast.

His grin softened a little bit into just the hint of a smile. His eyes were wide, like mine. All awe and lights. He touched my face, the way he'd touched my hand, as if he was trying to understand the shine.

"So pretty," he said. He left his hand against my cheek.

I'm not sure how long we stood there, smiling like total idiots, blazing away like glass torches.


I'm not sure either, SMeyer. XDDD

(BTW, Du can read the whole thing here if Du want:)

link
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
*
That excerpt's awesome thanks Momcat!!! That is the exact kind of scoop I had in mind and I'm glad it seems like SM's Schreiben is "improving" with practice :P. A "face beautiful with light"... :| have to admit I've never heard that one before!
snoznoodle posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
Thanks for the link, Dearheart. I think I'm going to read it right now because... I'm bored as well. And yes, curious. =P
rachaelwsz posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
Yeah, thanks!
MadamOcta13 posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
*
this one seems ok
14jcub posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr
chagrin91 said:
I just finished Lesen it and i loved it because it was just so sad and i Liebe sad stories it was really good
select as best answer
posted Vor mehr als einem Jahr 
next question »