Monkeys also believe in winning streaks, study shows 

Monkeys also believe in winning streaks, study shows

Humans have a well-documented tendency to see winning and losing streaks in situations that, in fact, are random. But scientists disagree about whether the “hot-hand bias” is a cultural artifact picked up in childhood or a predisposition deeply ingrained in the structure of our cognitive architecture.

Benjamin Hayden and his group study decision making in Rhesus monkeys at the University of Rochester and at a field site in Puerto Rico, where this photo was taken.

Humans have a well-documented tendency to see winning and losing streaks in situations that, in fact, are random. But scientists disagree about whether the "hot-hand bias" is a cultural artifact picked up in childhood or a predisposition deeply ingrained in the structure of our cognitive architecture.

Now in the first study in non-human primates of this systematic error in decision making, researchers find that monkeys also share our unfounded belief in winning and losing streaks. The results suggests that the penchant to see patterns that actually don\'t exist may be inherited -- an evolutionary adaptation that may have provided our ancestors a selective advantage when foraging for food in the wild, according to lead author Tommy Blanchard, a doctoral candidate in brain and cognitive sciences at the University of Rochester.

The cognitive bias may be difficult to override even in situations that are truly random. This inborn tendency to feel that we are on a roll or in a slump may help explain why gambling can be so alluring and why the stock market is so prone to wild swings, said coauthor Benjamin Hayden, assistant professor brain and cognitive sciences at the University of Rochester.

Hayden, Blanchard, and Andreas Wilke, an assistant professor of psychology at Clarkson University, reported their findings in the July issue of the

Journal of Experimental Psychology: Animal Learning and Cognition

To measure whether monkeys actually believe in winning streaks, the researchers had to create a computerized game that was so captivating monkeys would want to play for hours. "Luckily, monkeys love to gamble," said Blanchard. So the team devised a fast-paced task in which each monkey could choose right or left and receive a reward when they guessed correctly.

The researchers created three types of play, two with clear patterns (the correct answer tended to repeat on one side or to alternate from side to side) and a third in which the lucky pick was completely random. Where clear patterns existed, the three rhesus monkeys in the study quickly guessed the correct sequence. But in the random scenarios, the monkeys continued to make choices as if they expected a "streak." In other words, even when rewards were random, the monkeys favored one side.

The monkeys showed the hot-hand bias consistently over weeks of play and an average of 1,244 trials per condition. "They had lots and lots of opportunities to get over this bias, to learn and change, and yet they continued to show the same tendency," said Blanchard.

So why do monkeys and humans share this false belief in a run of luck even when faced over and over with evidence that the results are random? The authors speculate that the distribution of food in the wild, which is not random, may be the culprit. "If you find a nice juicy beetle on the underside of a log, this is pretty good evidence that there might be a beetle in a similar location nearby, because beetles, like most food sources, tend to live near each other," explained Hayden.

Evolution has also primed our brains to look for patterns, added Hayden. "We have this incredible drive to see patterns in the world, and we also have this incredible drive to learn. I think it\'s very related to why we like music, and why we like to do crossword puzzles, Sudoku, and things like that. If there\'s a pattern there, we\'re on top of it. And if there may or may not be a pattern there, that\'s even more interesting."

Understanding the hot-hand bias could inform treatment for gambling addiction and provide insights for investors, said Hayden. "If a belief in winning streaks is hardwired, then we may want to look for more rigorous retaining for individuals who cannot control their gambling. And investors should keep in mind that humans have an inherited bias to believe that if a stock goes up one day, it will continue to go up."

The results also could provide nuance to our understanding of free will, said Blanchard, who was drawn to the study of decision making during prior graduate training in philosophy. "Biases in our decision-making mechanisms, like this bias towards belief in winning and losing streaks, say something really deep about what sorts of creatures we are. We often like to think we make decisions based only on the information we\'re conscious of. But we\'re not always aware of why we make certain decisions or believe certain things.

"We\'re a complex mix of biases and heuristics and statistical reasoning. When you put it all together, that\'s how you get sophisticated behavior. We don\'t know where a lot of these biases come from, but this study -- and others like it -- suggest many of them are due to cognitive mechanisms we share with our primate relatives," said Blanchard.

This research was supported by grants from the National Science Foundation and the Brain and Behavior Research Foundation to Hayden.

The above story is based on materials provided by University of Rochester.

Tommy C. Blanchard, Andreas Wilke, Benjamin Y. Hayden. Hot-hand bias in rhesus monkeys..

University of Rochester. "Monkeys also believe in winning streaks, study shows." ScienceDaily. ScienceDaily, 27 June 2014. <www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/06/140627133101.htm>.

University of Rochester. (2014, June 27). Monkeys also believe in winning streaks, study shows. ScienceDaily. Retrieved June 29, 2014 from www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/06/140627133101.htm

University of Rochester. "Monkeys also believe in winning streaks, study shows." ScienceDaily. www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/06/140627133101.htm (accessed June 29, 2014).

June 27, 2014 � Scientists have successfully modified the precursor to one of the drugs used to treat tuberculosis, an important first step toward new drugs that can transcend antibiotic resistance issues. In 1993, ...

Monkeys Also Believe in Winning Streaks, Study Shows

June 27, 2014 � Humans have a well-documented tendency to see winning and losing streaks in situations that, in fact, are random. But scientists disagree about whether the “hot-hand bias” is a cultural artifact ...

Monkeys; Animal Learning and Intelligence; Intelligence; Consumer Behavior

Progress of Comprehensive Everglades Restoration Plan Evaluated

June 27, 2014 � Although planning for Everglades restoration projects has advanced considerably over the past two years, financial, procedural, and policy constraints have impeded project implementation, says a new ...

Environmental Awareness; Resource Shortage; Ecology; Ecology Research

June 27, 2014 � Climate change is predicted to have major impacts on the many species that call our rocky shorelines home. Indeed, species living in these intertidal habitats, which spend half their day exposed to ...

Environmental Issues; Global Warming; Nature; Environmental Awareness

A New Species of Moth from the Appalachian Mountains Named to Honor the Cherokee Nation

June 27, 2014 � A small, drab and highly inconspicuous moth has been flitting nameless about its special niche among the middle elevations of one of the world\'s oldest mountain ranges, the southern Appalachian ...

New Species; Nature; Insects (including Butterflies); Biology

Adding Sugar to High-Fat Western Diet Could Be Worse Than High-Fat Diet Alone

June 27, 2014 � A high-fructose, high-fat diet can cause harmful effects to the livers of adult rats, according to new research, providing new insight into the effects of adding fructose to a Western diet high in ...

Diet and Weight Loss; Obesity; Nutrition; Cholesterol

Scientists Identify New Microbes Linked to Severe Diarrhea

June 27, 2014 � Diarrhea is a major cause of childhood mortality in developing countries and ranks as one of the top four causes of death among young children in sub-Saharan Africa and South Asia. In a finding that ...

Children\'s Health; New Species; Biology; Health Policy

Some Dogs and Cats Prone to Sunburn: How to Protect Your Animal from Skin Damage

June 27, 2014 � Excessive sunbathing damages the skin. Humans are not the only ones who need to monitor their exposure to UV rays: animals are at risk too. Dogs and cats with white or thin coats are at particular ...

Notorious Pathogen Forms Slimy \'Streamers\' to Clog Up Medical Devices

June 26, 2014 � A group of researchers from the US has moved a step closer to preventing infections of the common hospital pathogen, Staphylococcus aureus, by revealing the mechanisms that allow the bacteria to ...

Bacteria; Extreme Survival; Infectious Diseases; Today\'s Healthcare

Noroviruses Cause Around a Fifth of All Cases of Acute Gastroenteritis Worldwide

June 26, 2014 � Noroviruses are a leading cause of acute gastroenteritis (diarrhea and vomiting) across all age groups, responsible for almost one-fifth of all cases worldwide. New estimates highlight the importance ...

Foodborne Illness; Healthy Aging; Public Health; Asthma

Monkeys Also Believe in Winning Streaks: Study

Moth Species Named in Honor of Cherokee Nation

Adding Sugar to High-Fat Diet Could Be Worse

from AP, Reuters, AFP, and other news services

Mobile Food Truck for Dogs Debuts in San Francisco

Reuters - US Online Video (June 28, 2014) � A mobile food truck in San Francisco says it\'s the first such food truck to cater only to canines, showing that eating on the run is going to the dogs. Mana Rabiee reports. Video provided by Reuters

Ugandan Gorillas Bring Tourist Dollars but Tensions Remain

AFP (June 28, 2014) � Gorilla tourism has brought economic growth to this community in south-western Uganda, but having one of the most densely populated rural areas on earth sit next door to these endangered animals continues to create conflict. Duration: 03:07 Video provided by AFP

Newly-Discovered Shrew And Elephant Are Long Lost Cousins

Newsy (June 27, 2014) � Researchers from California discovered a new type of elephant shrew that is more closely related to actual elephants than shrews. Video provided by Newsy

Lebanese Veterinary Clinics Raise Bar on Pets Welfare

AFP (June 27, 2014) � Pet owners from all over the Middle East have come to Lebanon for one of the region\'s leading veterinary hospitals in the Middle East. Duration: 01:00 Video provided by AFP

\'Bad\' Video Game Behavior Increases Morality?

Early Life Stress: Lasting Impacts on Brain

Do Gravitational Waves Exist? Neutron Star Clues

Researchers Detect Smallest Force Ever Measured

Feb. 17, 2014 � When a team goes on a multi-game winning streak, it has nothing to do with momentum, according to a new study. By examining varsity college hockey teams winning and losing record, researchers ...

What Do Investors and College Football Pollsters Have in Common?

Dec. 5, 2013 � When it comes to choosing the best college football teams in the nation or the best companies to invest in, even the experts tend to fall for the same types of biased thinking that the rest of us ...

Male Politicians Have \'Bigger Heads\' in More Gender-Equal Cultures

Oct. 17, 2012 � When it comes to analyzing gender stereotypes in the media, studies have shown that photographs of men focus on male faces while photographs of women are more focused on women\'s bodies. A recent ...

Oct. 5, 2011 � When an athlete consistently does well, sports commentators may describe them as being "hot" or "on fire." Scientists have debunked these streaks as being in the eye of the ...

Under Pressure: The Impact Of Stress On Decision Making

Sep. 15, 2009 � We are faced with making decisions all the time. Often, we carefully deliberate the pros and cons of our choices, taking into consideration past experiences in similar situations before making a ...

Mars \'flying saucer\' splashes back down after test

Mountain captured at Utah shopping center dies

NASA launches balloon carrying Mars ‘saucer’ prototype

Bum parachute mars NASA ‘saucer’ test flight

On eve of court ruling, Americans oppose contraceptive ban: Reuters/Ipsos poll

Study to track ticks moving north into Adirondacks

Many challenges face ex-inmates living with HIV

US company in Iowa churns out 100 cloned cows a year

Conservationists rally outside Yellowstone to protest wolf hunting

NASA\'s \'flying saucer\' tests new Mars-landing technology

Federal protection sought for wild horses in West

With new tech tools, precision farming gains traction

Google execs visit Cuba for first time to promote open Internet

Brazil win generates more Twitter traffic than Super Bowl

Winners named in global underwater robot event

Mars \'flying saucer\' splashes down after NASA test

Get the latest science news with ScienceDaily\'s free email newsletters, updated daily and weekly. Or view hourly updated newsfeeds in your RSS reader:

Keep up to date with the latest news from ScienceDaily via social networks and mobile apps:

Tell us what you think of ScienceDaily -- we welcome both positive and negative comments. Have any problems using the site? Questions?

About ScienceDaily �|� Editorial Staff �|� Awards & Reviews �|� Contribute News �|� Advertise with Us �|� Privacy Policy �|� Terms of Use

Content on this website is for informational purposes only. It is not intended to provide medical or other professional advice.

Views expressed here do not necessarily reflect those of ScienceDaily, its staff, its contributors, or its partners.

ScienceDaily features breaking news and videos about the latest discoveries in health, technology, the environment, and more -- from major news services and leading universities, scientific journals, and research organizations.

Read ScienceDaily\'s top medical sciences and health stories, or browse by topic:

Read ScienceDaily\'s top physical sciences and technology stories, or browse by topic:

Read ScienceDaily\'s top biological sciences and environment stories, or browse by topic:

Read ScienceDaily\'s strange and offbeat stories, or browse by topic:

Read ScienceDaily\'s top society and education stories, or browse by topic:

Latest Headlines Health & Medicine Mind & Brain Space & Time Matter & Energy Computers & Math Plants & Animals Earth & Climate Fossils & Ruins