Who likes the new judge, Ellen?

I think she is ok. I didnt like her going into it casue she doesnt really know much about music...but she actually gives semi-real Guter Rat all paula would say is "you look beautiful" and "I like your shoes they match your eyse" oder something along that sort. She was also kinda funny when she would make people step back and forth in the line then tell them they are all through (hollywood week)

I think she brings something new to the show.
She's funny.

she can lighten the mood like Paula did,
but unlike Paula she still give some real feedback.

I Liebe Ellen.
And I Liebe American Idol.

Hopefully she's good on it :)

she doesnt really have anything to do with music, but she's very funny and gives great advice. but the best judges are simon and kara!